Layout i did for a competition, rate it

[Coding4Newbs]

there site tieman.com.au

my layout: http://img219.imageshack.us/img219/9372/tiemancompetitionlayoutsywater.jpg

for them i could win 250$ closes tommrow 29th sunday,

Please rate it, im not the best but i gave it a go so tell me what you think

- sygon

[Coding4Newbs]

how come no one bloody replys to mine?

JoeyK. (Forum Moderator) - Please don't double post.

[,Alexx.]

Love it :) 10

[DanWilliamson]

Hey,

Not bad i've seen better but still it's pretty good

Few things could be improved.

7/10

- Dan

[Coding4Newbs]

Like dan? check out their website it matches what they wnt etc.

[ADAM:]

Great 9/10 :)

Some of the colours looked mucked up but that could be me.

- Adam

[Mr.Kylee]

Hey,

Not bad i've seen better but still it's pretty good

Few things could be improved.

7/10

- Dan
Try giving CC ''Dan''.

- Dan


oh and I love it :) hope you'll win.

[Coding4Newbs]

Thanks guys, if i win ill be so happy :), whats cc?
*edit worked it out consturctive critiscm

[DanWilliamson]

Hey,

Scroll through websites that i've replied to and you'll find that i'm one of the only ones that gives proper cc.

So go away and die you ****ing ****.

- Dan


Try giving CC ''Dan''.

- Dan


oh and I love it :) hope you'll win.

JoeyK. (Forum Moderator) - Please don't be rude.

[Olii]

Is that just a template made up in paint or any other image editor, or is it a proper coded website just not on the web?

[:Blob]

:O

I only just relaised what CC is

[Hobbit]

Pretty simple, not that pro for $250..

[JoeComins]

I've made betterfr alot lot less, but hey

[Jamie.]

sy its amazing 10/10 +rep

[Mentor]

Gives a proffecal look, not bad but cant realy judge a site from an image, since u can only see the look, not how its made, how efficant it is, or even how well it handles in diffent browsers all big factors in a good site "/

[Coding4Newbs]

Well, if i win or dont i will code it etc. with the dhtml, etc. and oli its not coded its a layout but i will code it, and who cares if its not worth 250$ joe, im entering it as a competition so stfu just because i didnt like your first 1 but hey i know it isnt that good i just wanted to see waht you guys though

- Sy

[JoeComins]

Sygon, What is your point exactly?

I'm just stating that if yu win, which you could, its not the best layout you could do for $250

[properclone]

it's ok, i googles the company and i much prefer their current one

[Coding4Newbs]

lol proper i gacve u the link there company is www.tieman.com.au there not choosing me its a comp, and joe - no comment

[Webhamster]

Could be worked on, overall ok. 6/10.

[Coding4Newbs]

which features?

[JoeComins]

The left navigation box. The letters in the boxes at th side are no of the best quality

Thanks

[Coding4Newbs]

What text?, sygon.monsterhost.org/tiemancomp/ heres a preview (mind the coding spent 5minutes) just as the rolovers would be

[Michael.]

a very professional layout. I can't help but feel though that the text is a little too small. but overall, a great layout and very acceptable for any company.

8 and a half / 10

[Coding4Newbs]

Thanks :) any more comments guys?

[DanWilliamson]

Hey,

You smell?

I mean it looks pretty professional after looking at it again.

- Dan

[JoeyK.]

I really like it... Way better than anything I could pull off at least ;)

9/10.

[Coding4Newbs]

Thanks, :) Im trying to create more proffesional looking designs i find it a bit blank :)

[fdb]

For the type of site it is it looks ok, the one thing you need to remember with sites like this is that you're not out to impress the hordes of webdesign gurus with fancy design or complicated scripts, you need to look at it from the eyes of the people who will actually use the site, who in most cases won't know or even care a great deal about site design and only want to access the info they need quickly and easily, the ultimate test would be to grab someone you know who knows little about the web and see how they get on with it but in this case i'd say you've done a good job there, everything looks intuative enough and the Flash advert is a good idea providing it's at a size that doesn't interfere with loading times.

As for it being a $250 prize, that sounds about right for a site like this, however once you start getting php logins and Flash involved you're looking at almost double that so they'd be getting a good deal for their money.
Have you seen any of the other entries or are they keeping that closed until the deadline?

[Coding4Newbs]

Yes ive seen other entries and they are way better than mine and im going to check whos won today :)