BBC Reboot feedback

[Luckyrare]

Hello, I would like some feedback on my BBC layout so far.

Now feedback, I would like you to say if you like it or not, why and how I can improve.

Thank you for your time!
Danny

http://****************/v1/uploads/e1fc9a4cef.png

[MattUH]

Love it, now that is BBC style!

[Luckyrare]

Love it, now that is BBC style!

Thanks, what needs improving?

[Flisker]

WOW, Nice layout :)

[craigg.]

Drop shaddow = Bad thing. Looks alright, in a way. Loose or put a low opacity on the drop shaddow, then it may look alright :)

[Luckyrare]

Drop shaddow = Bad thing. Looks alright, in a way. Loose or put a low opacity on the drop shaddow, then it may look alright :)

Hey, thanks for your feedback.

Drop shaddow was used with a darker colour due to the light background, using light colours will make the affect pointless. Thank you anyway ;)

Danny

[Billabong]

Its too boxy :rolleyes: try combining some boxes

[-::Mr.Dave::-]

**** WOW NOW THATS BBC

10/10
Maybe add a couple more images. Tv images and stuff

[Luckyrare]

Thanks, yes I may add some images. It is boxy due to organisation, people perfer sites that are easy to navigate. This breaks up the site and I think helps.

[timROGERS]

I still don't like it :( :P

[Luckyrare]

I still don't like it :( :P

So? I dont like yours and you have no design skill (http://www.lolz.co.uk)

LUFF U STILL TIM PLS?

Danny

[Sygon.]

I like the idea of it, you got the idea but need to position it right, remember were not designing for habbox people were designing for the bbc keep it proffesional that text used on the first nav at the very top is awful use a verdana 10px white non bold or bold also the shadow may not be neccary and Try use different color text ont he boxes i.e whites and blacks not just blacks, its gt alot of potential though, well done danny wouldnt expect it from you.

7.2/10.

[alexxxxx]

I still don't like it :( :P

Jealousy. I was going to apply, but my HTML/CSS isn't 100%. I would love a powerbook though.

[:Blob]

Ryan likes

Well done danny :D

8/10

[Luckyrare]

I like the idea of it, you got the idea but need to position it right, remember were not designing for habbox people were designing for the bbc keep it proffesional that text used on the first nav at the very top is awful use a verdana 10px white non bold or bold also the shadow may not be neccary and Try use different color text ont he boxes i.e whites and blacks not just blacks, its gt alot of potential though, well done danny wouldnt expect it from you.

7.2/10.
Thanks for the useful feedback, some people (http://www.tim-rogers.co.uk) cant give it.

I may use some of your feedback in my work.

TA LUFF


Jealousy. I was going to apply, but my HTML/CSS isn't 100%. I would love a powerbook though.

I WAS THINKING THAT! ;O I would love to win something, its something to do anyway ;P

& Thanks Ryan ;)

Danny

[Sygon.]

Thanks for the useful feedback, some people (http://www.tim-rogers.co.uk) cant give it.

I may use some of your feedback in my work.

TA LUFF



I WAS THINKING THAT! ;O

& Thanks Ryan ;)

Danny

Lol :D Thanks i love you (http://dannymilner.co.uk) two (http://tim-rogers.co.uk) in a brothwerly way

[timROGERS]

OK, as Danny is claiming that I'm jealous, here are the reasons that I dislike it:

- Would the BBC have gaming in the topbar?
- Would the BBC use Visitor, it's a non-standard font?
- I can't see the BBC using that many shadows, it makes it too dark
- How can you differentiate between links and normal text?
- All the colours are a little heavy, too dark imo

[craigg.]

in regards to your post, If the colours are to light, you should change those colours instead of adding things to the design to make it look right. Always select the correct background, then edit the colour if needed. Never add drop shaddow in such a way as it changes the look of the design in seconds, bringing the total asthetics down too.

Also, it is too boxy, and too plain, I think the BBC would like something more flexable to the user, in case of disabilities such as colur blindness, may be able to change the website to a lighter background and increase the font size etc.

It's these little personal touches which may help you win the competition, of course I am not going to give all of my ideas out, but that was a few ;)

[Timewarp]

Shocking it really hurts my eyes i mean YUCK thats MINGING 0/10
joking nice i like it 9/10

[Rob]

Very snazzy.

I like the whole design, but go easy on the drop shadow, and space the boxes more width ways. It looks too crammed in.

Rob

[Luckyrare]

Tim please read this...


Throw out the existing content, throw out the existing focus, throw out the existing expectations, limitations and assumptions

[Sygon.]

And fore mine


It could be just a search box