Rob Earnshaw

[:Hazel]

I was having a convo with my Dad the other day about whether Rob Earnshaw could cut it in the premier league.

He said no and I said yes. My arguement was that he is a prolific goalscorer and was never given a chance at West Brom.

I'm curious to what you think. Can he cut it? Poll included.

[Jamie!]

He is doing great in the Championship but don't know if he could be a prolific goalscorer in the Premier****, maybe a 10 goal a season guy?

[Immenseman]

I think he is an awesome player and could cut it in the premiership.

[:Chainz]

I think no IMO. He has set high standerds for him self in league 1 and the champo but the prem is tottalt a different level. The other day when i saw Palace V Norwich he wasnt all that he was hyped up to be, Huckerby seemed to have more flair than him.

[summer]

i think he could get 15 goals a season if he was in the right team and started regurlarly.