Hannah Montana, a FAKE!? [Discussion]

[PaulMacC]

http://youtube.com/watch?v=tDYhVzGmKY8

Watch that video and somewhere around 2:20 a person takes Miley Cyrus off the stage and replaces her with another one, they tried to cover it up but failed?

Your thoughts.

Similar threads merged by --ss-- (Forum Moderator): Both threads are on the same topic :).

[Smiddy]

You so heard about this on Scott Mill's radio 1 show earlier! but i'm glad you found it cos I couldn't remember what to search haha.

[Azul]

Yer but it’s part of the thing isn’t it, her identity is supposed to be a secret or whatever.

[PaulMacC]

Okay, I confess
Yes praise from the lord of the internets!
boo-shaka-laka-boo!


Azul, watch the video, it's a live show and someone takes her off the stage and replaces her with another look-a-like.
Watch the video before you comment.

[drama]

On the subject of the scott mills show - anyone tried f-cup cookies?

[PaulMacC]

Get your own thread mate, I want this topic to be discusssed, I need to see people thoughts.

[cocaine]

:S where does she get taken off to, i cant see her being switched..

[iCharlotte]

Lol at this, Im sure theres a reason for it soon to be told by miss cyrus.

[L!nK..]

lmao @ that

[dannyisnotamazing]

It's part of her best of both worlds tour and while she was changing into miley someone just changed into her for a minute, i heard and it was a while back anyway wern't it

[Azul]

*Text Removed*

Edited by opensourcehost (Forum Super Moderator): Please do not be rude.

[drama]

Scott mills said apparently its her dad with a wig :(

[Smiddy]

2:20 mark, Matt.

A dancer covers her in a blanket, takes her through 1 door, then pulls that door and another one comes out with a wig covering it's face.
lol at chappers saying it was her Dad hahaha.

[PaulMacC]

Heard of intervals?
Most concerts have them, well the ones that I've been too anyway.


Azul you have no right to call me a moron, this just displays your immaturaty.

[Azul]

Heard of intervals?
Most concerts have them, well the ones that I've been too anyway.


Azul you have no right to call me a moron, this just displays your immaturaty.

You had no right to assume I hadn't watched the video, and then tell me what to do.

[PaulMacC]

Did I say I had any right to tell you what to do?
How was I supposed to know you had watched the video, I only found out about it on the latest Scott Millis show


BTW People: Notice how she stills sings perfectly while inside a consealed room, lip-sync much?

[Azul]

You told me to watch the video before making a comment, so yes, obviously you did.

[PaulMacC]

And thousands of people probably use imperatives towards use each day yet I dont see you going up to them and complaining?

on topic: apparently she was lip-syncing according to the YT comments

[RedStratocas]

she's artificial enough as it is, i dont think this adds to anything.

[PaulMacC]

True, you obvious know it's not her though at the concert.

[Kardan]

Maybe she was ill and didn't want to let her 'fans' down? :rolleyes:

[PaulMacC]

Why would she perform for like 2 minutes though and then go?

If she was ill she surely would have pos-poned it or cancelled it and gave them refunds.

[Teyauna.]

It's apart of her act. She's not fake. I hate her anyways.

[dannyisnotamazing]

She came back on though, didn't she?

[RedStratocas]

True, you obvious know it's not her though at the concert.

my point is that it doesnt really matter whether it's her or not. if youve seen the show, its so artificial. her presence on stage isnt anything.. it's like calling out something in a cartoon that's physically impossible; it doesnt matter.

[le harry]

hannah montana sucks anyway.

[Metric.]

She is a fruit. She is going to be like britney spears.

[buttons]

hows that mean she's fake?!

[Clowgon]

I see her being taken off, but is'nt that just an act?

[Alkaz]

Maybe it is for a constume change or something?

but tbh half of them mime so who cares?

[lew!]

Those people payed alot of money to see her, and they get somone Lip syncing and a fake? pfft.

[Virgin Mary]

I thought she was like Hilary Duff or something, how is she real? I don't understand why she does that either... maybe she can't dance.

[Roboevil]

That's really random lol. It doesn't show the rest of it... maybe it was just a double so she could prepare for the next bit. I don't know why they covered her face though, she could've just slipped in.

[ItsDave]

Didnd't know if I should put it in Music or TV so I thought here.
Yeah she was on stage and some shocking things happened eh.
Video Link ere! Dunnoz if old.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tDYhVzGmKY8

[stratosphere]

My only friend Spleak told me this.

[-Sweex]

LOL this is all a act, so the next song she does she can change quicky, it’s kinda obvious, , i tought you would know that. and that’s obviously fake because she doesn’t wanna show her face.

MILEY CYRUS CAN’T CHANGE FAST, THAT’S WHY SHE HAS TO LEAVE EARLY.

Edited by --ss-- (Forum Super Moderator): Accidental multiple posts merged :)

[Hazza]

Heard of intervals?
Most concerts have them, well the ones that I've been too anyway.


Azul you have no right to call me a moron, this just displays your immaturaty.
She might of replaced herself with someone because she may of had a quick change?
and Paul most singers lip-sync nowadays, because they can't sing without the help of a old computer;).

the sugababes in concert? They are absolutely rubbish in concert and 2 of them can't even sing :rolleyes:.

[Favourtism]

She might of replaced herself with someone because she may of had a quick change?
and Paul most singers lip-sync nowadays, because they can't sing without the help of a old computer;).

the sugababes in concert? They are absolutely rubbish in concert and 2 of them can't even sing :rolleyes:.
I heard Sugababes live and yeah they are rubbish. Radio/CD= Serious Sound Editing :P

My sister watches Hanna Montana :(

[cocaine]

2:20 mark, Matt.

A dancer covers her in a blanket, takes her through 1 door, then pulls that door and another one comes out with a wig covering it's face.
lol at chappers saying it was her Dad hahaha.

cheers lol the vid said 2:10 :S

[Hazza]

I heard Sugababes live and yeah they are rubbish. Radio/CD= Serious Sound Editing :P

My sister watches Hanna Montana :(
Seriously. The sugababes are rubbish.

I mean if you were a 14 year old girl, how much stress and pressure this must put on you to be doing this. I mean give her a break? It was one song for like 40 seconds and for the lip-sync issue, I'm not surprised most singers lip-sync now, how must strain singing must have on your voice?

I'm a singer myself and its best not to sing plenty of songs everyday for months :P!

[Assassinator]

Tbh i dont think she cares she has made her millions, and i think just somehow the thousands of people watching her would relise if it was a fake? -_-

[Virgin Mary]

Seriously. The sugababes are rubbish.

I mean if you were a 14 year old girl, how much stress and pressure this must put on you to be doing this. I mean give her a break? It was one song for like 40 seconds and for the lip-sync issue, I'm not surprised most singers lip-sync now, how must strain singing must have on your voice?

I'm a singer myself and its best not to sing plenty of songs everyday for months :P!
Singing isn't straining at all if you do it right. People in theatre do it and they sing much bigger songs than people like hannah montana.

[Hazza]

Singing isn't straining at all if you do it right. People in theatre do it and they sing much bigger songs than people like hannah montana.
and how old are they?

and they do not sing as many songs as people in concerts.
I do understand what you mean and your voice does strain if you do it everyday, big songs and stuff. You need to rest your voice!

Could you cope with all the stuff she does?

[Virgin Mary]

and how old are they?

and they do not sing as many songs as people in concerts.
I do understand what you mean and your voice does strain if you do it everyday, big songs and stuff. You need to rest your voice!

Could you cope with all the stuff she does?
Yes, it's pop songs lol.

[Mr.Sam]

How about opera singers?



and how old are they?

and they do not sing as many songs as people in concerts.
I do understand what you mean and your voice does strain if you do it everyday, big songs and stuff. You need to rest your voice!

Could you cope with all the stuff she does?

[beth]

and how old are they?

and they do not sing as many songs as people in concerts.
I do understand what you mean and your voice does strain if you do it everyday, big songs and stuff. You need to rest your voice!

Could you cope with all the stuff she does?
there are children singing in stage shows 8 days a week.

[Hazza]

There's not 8 days in a week and not many 'children' sing solo in the west end, choirs yes. But thats easy.;).
Tbh, I could most probably do what she does.
But I just believe it was for a quick change.

I'm not a big fan of Hannah, but I think people should cut her some slack.

[PaulMacC]

That connie girl from Britains Got Talent.

[Hazza]

That connie girl from Britains Got Talent.
Lol, like she does concerts:rolleyes:.

[Virgin Mary]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lD8RV6nw480
LOL!!!!!!!!!! LET'S SEE HANNAH MONTANA DO THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lew!]

^^
An eyeee tail yu eye no goingggggggg

But yeah, People still paid to see her, and they dont expect a fake

[beth]

There's not 8 days in a week and not many 'children' sing solo in the west end, choirs yes. But thats easy.;).
Tbh, I could most probably do what she does.
But I just believe it was for a quick change.

I'm not a big fan of Hannah, but I think people should cut her some slack.
8 days a week, is a theatrical term, as shows play everyday plus a sunday matinee in the west end.
and also; there are children singing leads. mary poppins, cats, chitty chitty bang bang, oliver and others spring to mind.

[Naythi.]

God.

They could of done it better.

They shouldnt of done that, even if its for all the reasons you guys were saying.

They should of told the fans, shouldnt they get done?

[Hazza]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lD8RV6nw480
LOL!!!!!!!!!! LET'S SEE HANNAH MONTANA DO THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL at thattttttt.
pretty good tho.

[Hazza]

8 days a week, is a theatrical term, as shows play everyday plus a sunday matinee in the west end.
and also; there are children singing leads. mary poppins, cats, chitty chitty bang bang, oliver and others spring to mind.
It's 8 shows a week not days;).

How many of you sing yourself? I mean on a stage?

Edited by PeaceOfMind (Forum Moderator): Please do not double post.

[Mr.Sam]

if she can't do the however many shows they are doing they shouldn't of booked so many in a small time space.


It's 8 shows a week not days;).

How many of you sing yourself? I mean on a stage?

[Hazza]

if she can't do the however many shows they are doing they shouldn't of booked so many in a small time space.
Well, when there is money involved... ;)

[Mr.Sam]

all those fans will complain and demand some sort of refund and others will just not bother going if it isn't the real person and is all mimed.


Well, when there is money involved... ;)

[Hazza]

all those fans will complain and demand some sort of refund and others will just not bother going if it isn't the real person and is all mimed.
And so would I.
But i'm saying give her a break.

It was most probably, 1 mimed song and she only faked it for like 40 seconds.

[Nuxty]

lol - shes not the best of singers. bit of a scandle thou ;o

[Mitch4?]

Most child actors in the west end despite having 8 shows a week, will only play about 2-3 nights. They have 2-3 of each child actor.
Yeah i love hannah montanna cause im a big kid, but so what?
Yeah she did this, it probebly wasn't her choice anyway, it most likely got thrust on her that she had to do it anyway. xo.