Should School Pupils Be Allowed To...

[Beaustique]

Should school pupils have the right to chat in class while the teacher is not talking and work is to be completed, is it wrong for the teacher to punish pupils for simply have a social chat and enjoying themself instead of sitting on there own doing there work bored? Just answer the poll and let out your view in this question.

[Warezkid2]

They should be, but you get all types of problems ;/

[jesus]

yes it should, theres nothing wrong with it as long as they are working and its controlled


They should be, but you get all types of problems ;/
like what?

examples would be nice

[Smiddy]

If they're working as well as chatting, then yes, all for it; the same can be said if they've completed the set work.
If they're someone who's a slow worker, and stops writing to talk to others (IE - turns around) - then no, they should not be allowed to talk.

But the same rule has to apply to everybody.

[Warezkid2]

yes it should, theres nothing wrong with it as long as they are working and its controlled


like what?

examples would be nice


Safety rules ect, it some times they go on and go on, and it takes like 5 mins to shut the class up for a 2 min speak.

[jesus]

Safety rules ect, it some times they go on and go on, and it takes like 5 mins to shut the class up for a 2 min speak.i dont see how that can affect someones safety

if you read my first post, you'll see that i said its a good idea if its controlled and they are getting on with their work.

[Warezkid2]

i dont see how that can affect someones safety

if you read my first post, you'll see that i said its a good idea if its controlled and they are getting on with their work.



How am i meant to comment on that when your post is just after mine? :rolleyes:.


and yes, the safety laws are getting tougher, so yeh, they wont allow it ;/

[jesus]

nobodys talking about safety! there is no safety issue in the topic which is being discussed, so stop posting pointlessly.

[Warezkid2]

nobodys talking about safety! there is no safety issue in the topic which is being discussed, so stop posting pointlessly.

I'm loling at you, this thread is about should they be allowed to, i saying i think they should, but it not gonna happen becasue of these reasons :rolleyes::D

[jesus]

I'm loling at you, this thread is about should they be allowed to, i saying i think they should, but it not gonna happen becasue of these reasons :rolleyes::Dso talking is unsafe is it?

[Warezkid2]

so talking is unsafe is it?

yeh? :rolleyes: if they dont listen and continuing talking, don't forget, we talking about deaf people as well, blind people, not everything perfect :rolleyes:

[jesus]

yeh? :rolleyes: if they dont listen and continuing talking, don't forget, we talking about deaf people as well, blind people, not everything perfect :rolleyes:i honestly fail to see how this has any relevance to anything at all.

but OKAY. you carry on thinking the way you think and trying to explain in your own little ways.

as mentioned, i've voted yes :)

[Warezkid2]

I speak in plain English


i honestly fail to see how this has any relevance to anything at all.

This thread, says, Should pupils be allowed to talk when the teacher not talking.
Well, i replied, saying it gonna cuase problems,

1. Safety health issues, which wont make it happen.
2. It gonna take a hell of time to get the students to shut up when the teacher needs to talk again.
3.If you mean above, disbled people need extra help, and i dont think it would work, since some deaf people work in mainstream schools, and dont need students talking to the teachers.


but OKAY. you carry on thinking the way you think and trying to explain in your own little ways.

I lol'd hard
as mentioned, i've voted yes :)

Okay?


P.s, What with the ******* bold?

[Mentor]

Depends on circumstances, sometimes sure, other times not. Tis really up to the teachers "/

[Neversoft]

No, they will get distracted. Learning in silence is more effective and educational.

[jesus]

No, they will get distracted. Learning in silence is more effective and educational.they tend to get distracted then, as they get bored usually and find other silly little things to do!

it is probably better than letting them talk though

[Neversoft]

they tend to get distracted then, as they get bored usually and find other silly little things to do!

it is probably better than letting them talk though


What the hell did you just say!? :P

[Warezkid2]

they tend to get distracted then, as they get bored usually and find other silly little things to do!

it is probably better than letting them talk though



Another reason, when people talk, they dont think about there work,

oh your gonna say, ye some do, but maybe not 20% of UK, which is alot :)

[Herman]

your question is too broad. of course students should be allowed to talk, but it really depends on the situation. if, for example, a group of students have finished their work and talk extremely loudly amongst themselves, then it is definitely unfair to the rest who have not finished.

we as students sometimes take our teachers for granted. you have to understand their feelings too, they're trying to conduct a good lesson and there you are, blabbering away, distracting both the teacher and the rest of the students.

[BlueLord]

They should providing they're respectful to the teacher & quiet when they're told to be.

[today]

Depends on circumstances, sometimes sure, other times not. Tis really up to the teachers "/
I agree from time to time yes talking is part of learning but not all the time and can often be abused.