Pulling out? What stays? [poll]

[Hypertext]

Vote on if somebody joins a team to do something for instance a project and designs graphics, if they pull out who keeps the graphics?

YES = Designer
or
NO = the projec


Thx

[TidgyPie]

Vote on if somebody joins a team to do something for instance a project and designs graphics, if they pull out who keeps the graphics?

YES?
or
NO?


Thx


that dosent make sense

[Hypertext]

If person a does something for person b, in a non-contract signed project.. who keeps it

person a or person b


IF person A walks out.

[Kieran]

The project would if they agreed to make it for that.
Once they hand it over it becomes the sole use of the project.

[Gangster]

If person a does something for person b, in a non-contract signed project.. who keeps it

person a or person b


IF person A walks out.
Makes it more confusing even though i know what you mean.

Basically what he's saying it If 2 people are starting a project Bob and John. If John creates a graphic for the project, then 1 week later the doesn't want to do the project anymore. Who keeps the graphics? John or does it belong to the project?

[Hypertext]

Correct.

[Kieran]

Thats like saying a Habbo pixel artist can make a design, then Habbo use it. The pixel artist quits and asks them to take it off! Well they wont because it becomes their property to do with what they want.

[Plux]

I designed it all, but i signed no OFFICIAL contract handing it over to Flyxa.
So all work is mine. :)

and nothing has been copyrighted by them. Soo :)

[Kieran]

No, if you were working for them at the time of designing it, and let them use it, it becomes their property.

[Plux]

No, if you were working for them at the time of designing it, and let them use it, it becomes their property.

No contract was signed.
It's my work.

[Kieran]

A contract wouldn't need to be signed if you designed it for them whilst working for them!

[Plux]

A contract wouldn't need to be signed if you designed it for them whilst working for them!

I was senior graphics designer, so all work, would be done for me to be verified, then passed on, I handled GFX. So it is mine.

Learn law pls.

[Hypertext]

Thats what I thought ;/

[Dentafrice]

If I designed a system for Microsoft, they decided not to use it, they couldn't keep it nor the rights to it.

It is my system, and I own it.

Unless you sign a contract, where all you work goes to that project/company, the work is still yours.

[Kieran]

You've just shot yourself in the foot there then:

"I was SENIOR GRAPHICS DESIGNER" - Is it me, or does this mean all graphics were made for that site?!

Therefore, they become thiers! I think you need to learn copyright laws.

[Plux]

If I designed a system for Microsoft, they decided not to use it, they couldn't keep it nor the rights to it.

It is my system, and I own it.

Unless you sign a contract, where all you work goes to that project/company, the work is still yours.


Point prooven. :)

[Hypertext]

But he was working for us at the time.

Off-topic: I love how you rephrased Apple to Microsoft, at risk of being flamed. =]

[rawritsluke]

If josh signed no contract josh keeps the gfx he made. If he signed a contract meaning you both have soul ownership via them charlie could keep the gfx and josh could too.

Seeing as this is not a publically released company yet I'd say josh should be able to keep HIS gfx.

[Dentafrice]

You've just shot yourself in the foot there then:

"I was SENIOR GRAPHICS DESIGNER" - Is it me, or does this mean all graphics were made for that site?!

Therefore, they become thiers! I think you need to learn copyright laws.
Read what is in this:

http://www.proposalkit.com/htm/IT_web_software_hardware_contracts/ownership_transfer_contracts/writers_transfer_of_copyright_contract.htm

Same thing.


But he was working for us at the time.

Off-topic: I love how you rephrased Apple to Microsoft, at risk of being flamed. =]

Are you stupid? I don't see how one company could start a "flame war", fine watch this. I don't care?


--------

If I designed a system for Apple, they decided not to use it, they couldn't keep it nor the rights to it.

It is my system, and I own it.

Unless you sign a contract, where all you work goes to that project/company, the work is still yours.

---

If I designed a system for Google, they decided not to use it, they couldn't keep it nor the rights to it.

It is my system, and I own it.

Unless you sign a contract, where all you work goes to that project/company, the work is still yours.

----

If I designed a system for someotherrandomcompany, they decided not to use it, they couldn't keep it nor the rights to it.

It is my system, and I own it.

Unless you sign a contract, where all you work goes to that project/company, the work is still yours.

[Hypertext]

But he designed them for US.

[Plux]

But he designed them for US.

Actually, I designed it for my benefit in experiance and my portfolio.

[Hypertext]

Thread closed.