Re: GTA IV

[Discharge Man]

Okay, why the hell did you close the thread?

GommeInc and I are mature enough to not turn the debate into an argument and from where I'm sitting it was just that, a debate.

[GommeInc]

It was closed?! :S How come? A debate has arguments, an argument was 'make a GTA IV forum' so people made a counter argument saying it isn't needed :S Arguments aren't flame wars "/

[Discharge Man]

Idiotic, that's what they are.

Alex was eager to press the close button - his twitch made him do so.

[-Xiangu-]

The forum isn't needed as it is only one game.

[ThyGoat]

I've given up hope REMOVED

Edited by jesus (Forum Super Moderator): Please do not avoid the language filter.

[-Eyeless-]

Idiotic, that's what they are.

Alex was eager to press the close button - his twitch made him do so.

Once again your method of getting something implemented (yes, it is perfect english) is totally flawed, calling people idiotic doesn't show you in a particularly good light. I am only suggesting ways in which you could try to get a GTA sub-forum, so do not, and I quote
urn the debate into an argument Which is what you seem to do...

:)

[dirrty]

The forum isn't needed as it is only one game.
big brother forum isnt needed as its only one programme.

[-Eyeless-]

big brother forum isnt needed as its only one programme.

However, Big Brother happens all year round,whether it be American BB or English BB etc...

Whereas GTA release a game, hmm once every 3 years? So yes people will talk about it for the first month or so. The only way to tell if it is really neccesary to have a subforum is if people are still talking about it for months afterwards, which you cannot predict... Case closed I think?

EDIT: oh and if people ARE still talking about then (as much as they are now) then by all means try your luck with a sub-forum again. But in my opinion you sound like spoilt brats (OHHH GIVE ME A SUB-FORUM for everything under the sun!)....

[GommeInc]

I suggest both forums don'tt exist, BB only need to be around when it is around and the GTA IV doesn't really need to exist, when there aren't a heaping load of threads!

[-Eyeless-]

I suggest both forums don'tt exist, BB only need to be around when it is around and the GTA IV doesn't really need to exist, when there aren't a heaping load of threads!

Then again BB is around in each quater... so it is much more neccesary than GTA, but I do agree that neither is really important enough...

[GommeInc]

I guess it depends on which BB. Perhaps moving the thread into the Television forum when the UK and US versions aren't around? I think the Big Brother forum argument is linked to the proposed idea of having an Anime/Manga sub-forum, because someone said Anime is a fad, yet it is just a genre which is quite popular in film, art and television which seems reasonable for a trial forum. But that argument seems to have died down.

[-Xiangu-]

big brother forum isnt needed as its only one programme.

Exactly I don't think it should either.

[-Eyeless-]

I guess it depends on which BB. Perhaps moving the thread into the Television forum when the UK and US versions aren't around? I think the Big Brother forum argument is linked to the proposed idea of having an Anime/Manga sub-forum, because someone said Anime is a fad, yet it is just a genre which is quite popular in film, art and television which seems reasonable for a trial forum. But that argument seems to have died down.

Hmm I wouldn't say that Anime/Manga is a fad in general terms but I have to say that people on the forum "seem" to like things one day then CBa the next...lol and Anime/Manga is a prime example...

[GommeInc]

Hmm I wouldn't say that Anime/Manga is a fad in general terms but I have to say that people on the forum "seem" to like things one day then CBa the next...lol and Anime/Manga is a prime example...
Indeed, it's hard to deal with things like this for the council (or to sort out something), so I dare not know what the management have to put up with, although a little message saying they're dealing with it wouldn't go a miss :)

[nvrspk4]

Mm that debate was constructive, I think its unfair to say that he was triggerhappy, he may have made a mistake or he may have been looking at earlier threads, but I have reopened the thread as the debate ocurring there seemed to be rather productive, but certain members *cough* would do well to stay out of the thread as they don't have many positive comments to make.

Thanks :)

[AgnesIO]

Hmm is it really that bigger deal if the thread is opened or closed. I mean what is the big deal about GTA IV?! It would be silly to have a forum as only ps3 and xbox 360 users would care.

Also don't you think it is a bit unfair to say the MOD was waiting for a moment to close the thread?