Referee decisions

[Minstrels]

Post below what referee decisions you've seen which they have blates got wrong. I'll start.

Man City vs Liverpool - Player raked Jo without even a booking http://img219.imageshack.us/img219/8428/ss100407ko4vo2.jpg
Wigan vs Man City - Penalty, player dived.
Newcastle vs Man City - Robinho dived.
Mboro vs Man City - Contact was outside of the box.

[Heart Break Kid]

the Boro one i must admit shouldnt of been a foul anyway
but seeming as lately we have had great penalty appeals turned away it was nice to get a break :)

[Minstrels]

I'm trying to blame it on these it's just I'm trying to do some research for something which I'll post if it patches together. Didn't something happen in the Blackburn vs Manchester United game? Did United get an offside goal or something? And Manchester United got a penalty against Bolton for the dive didn't they? Then Terry got a red card resinded (sp?) didn't he? Can someone clarify for me? Cheers.

[Earthquake]

Maybe he never saw it? But hey!

[brandon]

We've given away like 8 penalties this season and some of them are controversial to say the least.

[Minstrels]

Maybe he never saw it? But hey!
But hey, I'm sure he did. Look at the image, how can you not see it?


We've given away like 8 penalties this season and some of them are controversial to say the least.
What team is this? Norwich? Sorry but I'm researching the PL because that's where the "Top Four" play. :(

[Earthquake]

But hey, I'm sure he did. Look at the image, how can you not see it?


What team is this? Norwich? Sorry but I'm researching the PL because that's where the "Top Four" play. :(
lol good point, maybe it was mis-timed?

[Minstrels]

lol good point, maybe it was mis-timed?
If it was mis-timed then surely it should be a freekick? ;)

[brandon]

But hey, I'm sure he did. Look at the image, how can you not see it?


What team is this? Norwich? Sorry but I'm researching the PL because that's where the "Top Four" play. :(
Yeah. :(

[Minstrels]

Yeah. :(
Maybe next year you can post when your in the PL? :(

[brandon]

Maybe next year you can post when your in the PL? :(
:( See you then I hope

[Captain]

Mboro vs Man City - Contact was outside of the box.

The players feet were in the box though. Although it was a harsh penalty, Boro still pooned.

[Minstrels]

:( See you then I hope
Please refrain from posting in any of my threads in the sports section until we're in the same league. :D

[Captain]

Please refrain from posting in any of my threads in the sports section until we're in the same league. :D
LOL :D

[Jack.Lfc]

I thought skrtels tackle was brilliant myself.

[Minstrels]

I thought skrtels tackle was brilliant myself.
I don't think you can class it as a tackle because he didn't touch the ball. ;)

[Geraint]

The ronaldo penalty against Bolton (I think) was bad.

[Minstrels]

The ronaldo penalty against Bolton (I think) was bad.
Cheers, so that's another which helps a top four side. :)

[Jack.Lfc]

I don't think you can class it as a tackle because he didn't touch the ball. ;)

The ball is about to drop onto him, won the ball cleanly.

[Minstrels]

The ball is about to drop onto him, won the ball cleanly.
After he raked a player so it was hardly clean. :P

[Jack.Lfc]

After he raked a player so it was hardly clean. :P

Careful if he reads this he will hunt you down and eat you alive.

http://img.skysports.com/08/01/218x298/Martin_Skrtel_624017.jpg

[Captain]

Nice of you to post a picture of yourself Jack but you should post that in the expose yourself thread.

[Jack.Lfc]

Nice of you to post a picture of yourself Jack but you should post that in the expose yourself thread.

Oh dear, we have a comedian

[Captain]

I try my best.