Most Over/Under Rated player in England.

[sock]

imo..

Under - Daniel Agger

Over - Quarsema

[Wootzeh]

Over: robinho
Under: ryan shawcrossssss

[Rarelime]

Under ~ Michael Dawson

Over ~ Nani

[Browney]

Under: Park
Over: Lampard

[Excellent2]

Under: Ashley young
Over: Federico macheda

Reason for above;
He's only had 2 games at top flight level. Even though I'm a United fan I think everyone has jumped on the band wagon too soon.

[Chaos]

nvmmmm

[Georgie-Best]

Under- Carrick
Over- Carragher, Reina, Gerrard

[Georgie-Best]

Under ~ Michael Dawson

Over ~ Nani
Who over rates Nani?

Most United fans think he is rubbish..

Edited by preposterous (Forum Moderator) - Please don't double post.

[Scouse]

under: benayoun

over: lampard

[Skajo]

Under: Ashley young
Over: Federico macheda

Reason for above;
He's only had 2 games at top flight level. Even though I'm a United fan I think everyone has jumped on the band wagon too soon.
3 games.

Over; Nani
Under; Modric (If Spurs never had this kid this season, they'd be toast).

[Loser]

Too many choices for overrated, but for underrated, I'll go with Michael Carrick.

[Bun]

Who over rates Nani?

Most United fans think he is rubbish..

Edited by preposterous (Forum Moderator) - Please don't double post.
maybe fans of other teams?



over: nani
under: johnson (when he gets his game) :eusa_wall

[Skajo]

The price Funguson paid for Nani suggests how highly he rated him...

[leah]

Over - Ronaldo *step over, dives, cries*
Under - Carragher - he's really dedicated, hard working and a great defender but no one really mentions him.

[Twist]

Under: Ashley young
Over: Federico macheda

Reason for above;
He's only had 2 games at top flight level. Even though I'm a United fan I think everyone has jumped on the band wagon too soon.
Have you even seen him play? Or did you just read the papers and automatically assume he is crap :S?

Under- Carrick
Over- Carragher, Reina, Gerrard
Lol idiot.

Edited by preposterous (Forum Moderator) - Please don't insult other members.

[sock]

actually in fact i'll add to my list..

Under - Jason Scotland, Michael Carrick, Luka Modric

Over - Dimitar Berbatov, Anderson, Reina, Paul Robinson

[Twist]

actually in fact i'll add to my list..

Under - Jason Scotland, Michael Carrick, Luka Modric

Over - Dimitar Berbatov, Anderson, Reina, Paul Robinson
Didn't realise anyone actually rated Robinson anymore :P.
Is he Blackburn's number 1 still? Haven't heard his name mentioned in time.

[sock]

ye he is but he's a pile of crapp

[Jack.Lfc]

Over: Anderson, Ferdinand (watch him when vidic is injured, he's all over the place, vidic carries him)
Under: Tim Cahill

[JackBuddy]

Over: Any United youngster. Richard Eckersley is soooo good.
Under: Benayoun, Matty Taylor.

[Captain]

Over rated: Downing/Rooney
Under rated: Beayoun/Carrick

[Georgie-Best]

Over - Ronaldo *step over, dives, cries*
Under - Carragher - he's really dedicated, hard working and a great defender but no one really mentions him.
Clueless.

[Jibbish]

Over rated: Ronaldo
Under Rated: Luke Young

[Cisse9]

Underated: Alex Song
Overated: Nani and Anderson, i know there young but for the money payed it is a joke almost £40mill spent on them both.

[sock]

under as well - diaby

[Geraint]

Over - Ronaldo *step over, dives, cries*
Under - Carragher - he's really dedicated, hard working and a great defender but no one really mentions him.

Carragher? Under-rated? You're having a laugh. In my opinion, he is the most over-rated player in the Premier League.

[Soy]

Over - Reigna, Gerrard and Nani

Under - Jenas Lennon Modric

[Ardemax]

over: reina

under: arshavin (he's not that crap liverpool fans)

[JackBuddy]

Over - Reigna, Gerrard and Nani

Under - Jenas Lennon Modric
Jenas is rubbish. The only thing he has going for himself is his pace... which he doesn't use. Huddlestone is so much better and distributing the ball.

Gerrard in my opinon has been the most consistent and best player in the league this season.