Game comparisons.

[dbgtz]

Compare the games that you prefer or think you will/would prefer.
Battlefield:BC2 <-> MW2
Heavy Rain <-> Alan Wake
Halo 3 <-> Killzone 2 <-> Red Steel 2
New Super Mario Bros Wii <-> Littlebigplanet <-> Viva Pinata (or w/e)
GTA IV <-> Saints Row 2
MGS4 <-> Splinter Cell (the one coming soonish forgot the name).
Uncharted 2 <-> Tomb Raider (the newest one lol).
Gears of war 2 <-> Quantum Theory
Street Fighter IV(?) <-> Tekken 6
Assassin's Creed II <-> Prince of Persia <-> Arkham Asylum
Lego Star Wars <-> Lego Batman
All the CODs

Mine are:
MW2
Heavy Rain
KZ2
LBP
GTA
MGS4 (Splinter looks too similar too AC in mechanics).
Uncharted 2
Gears 2
Don't play fighters
ACII
Lego star wars
COD4 at the time

[Nuct]

Battlefield:BC2
Heavy Rain
Halo 3
Little Big Planet
Saints Row 2
MGS4
Uncharted 2
Gears Of War 2
Tekken 6
Assassin's Creed II
Lego Star Wars
Neither of the COD games, hate them all.

[Stryderman]

Compare the games that you prefer or think you will/would prefer.
MW2
Heavy Rain
Killzone 2
Viva Pinata i love that game
Saints row 2
Splinter cell
Uncharted 2
Quantum Theory
Tekken 6
Assassin's Creed II
Lego Batman
Cod waw

[Fez]

Pretty stupid comparisons really.

[B]Battlefield:BC2 = MW2 - Two completely different centred multiplayer games.

Heavy Rain <-> Alan Wake - Heavy Rain is unique, you can't really compare it with anything

Halo 3 <-> Killzone 2 <-> Red Steel 2 - Are we bringing Wii games in this? They don't count. Halo sucks.

New Super Mario Bros Wii <-> Littlebigplanet <-> Viva Pinata (or w/e) - the (w/e) pretty much says it all. If you're looking for a family game, just buy a Wii because everybody is stupid.

GTA IV < Saints Row 2 - Only good one. Saints Row 2

MGS4 <-> Splinter Cell (the one coming soonish forgot the name). - Conviction. MGS4 is MGS, Conviction just reinvents everything. No comparison.

Uncharted 2 <-> Tomb Raider (the newest one lol). - This one is just a joke

Gears of war 2 <-> Quantum Theory - LOL GEARS 2 VS GEARS 2 CLONE HMM

Street Fighter IV(?) <-> Tekken 6 - button masher ntythx

Assassin's Creed II <-> Prince of Persia <-> Arkham Asylum - Really between Arkham and Assassin's Creed 2. In which case, I can decide.

Lego Star Wars <-> Lego Batman - Both the same.

All the CODs - World at War/ 4

[Jam]

Battlefield: Bad Company 2 - Modern Warfare 2
Heavy Rain - Alan Wake
Halo 3 - Killzone 2 - Red Steel 2
New Super Mario Bros Wii - LittleBigPlanet - Viva Pinata
GTA IV - Saints Row 2
MGS4 - Splinter Cell Conviction
Uncharted 2 - Tomb Raider
Gears of War 2 - Quantum Theory NEITHER
Street Fighter IV - Tekken 6 NEITHER
Assassin's Creed II - Prince of Persia - Arkham Asylum
Lego Star Wars - Lego Batman
Call of Duty's NONE

[dbgtz]

Pretty stupid comparisons really.

Battlefield:BC2 = MW2 - Two completely different centred multiplayer games.

Heavy Rain <-> Alan Wake - Heavy Rain is unique, you can't really compare it with anything

Halo 3 <-> Killzone 2 <-> Red Steel 2 - Are we bringing Wii games in this? They don't count. Halo sucks.

New Super Mario Bros Wii <-> Littlebigplanet <-> Viva Pinata (or w/e) - the (w/e) pretty much says it all. If you're looking for a family game, just buy a Wii because everybody is stupid.

GTA IV < Saints Row 2 - Only good one. Saints Row 2

MGS4 <-> Splinter Cell (the one coming soonish forgot the name). - Conviction. MGS4 is MGS, Conviction just reinvents everything. No comparison.

Uncharted 2 <-> Tomb Raider (the newest one lol). - This one is just a joke

Gears of war 2 <-> Quantum Theory - LOL GEARS 2 VS GEARS 2 CLONE HMM

Street Fighter IV(?) <-> Tekken 6 - button masher ntythx

Assassin's Creed II <-> Prince of Persia <-> Arkham Asylum - Really between Arkham and Assassin's Creed 2. In which case, I can decide.

Lego Star Wars <-> Lego Batman - Both the same.

[B]All the CODs - World at War/ 4

Theyre not really stupid as they're similar or compared to alot. Also the w/e was for the fact I didn't know how to spell it.

[ecstasy]

Battlefield:BC2 > MW2
Heavy Rain > Alan Wake - Only because I dont know about Alan Wake. Im not sure if im missing the point with Heavy Rain but it just seems like one big interative cut scene to me, I dont see why that would be any fun at all.
Halo 3 < Killzone 2 > Red Steel 2
New Super Mario Bros Wii < Littlebigplanet > Viva Pinata (or w/e)
GTA IV > Saints Row 2
MGS4 > Splinter Cell (the one coming soonish forgot the name).
Uncharted 2 > Tomb Raider (the newest one lol).
Gears of war 2 <-> Quantum Theory Neither
Street Fighter IV(?) <-> Tekken 6 Neither
Assassin's Creed II > Prince of Persia < Arkham Asylum
Lego Star Wars > Lego Batman
All the CODs 4

[ItsDave]

Compare the games that you prefer or think you will/would prefer.
MW2
Heavy Rain
Halo 3
Littlebigplanet
GTA IV
Splinter Cell
Uncharted 2
Gears of war 2
Tekken 6
Assassin's Creed II
Lego Star Wars
CoD4

[Black_Apalachi]

Strike through = haven't played.
Italics = my choice.
No italics = not a big fan.

Battlefield:BC2 - MW2
Heavy Rain - Alan Wake
Halo 3 - Killzone 2 - Red Steel 2
New Super Mario Bros Wii - LittleBigPlanet - Viva Pinata (or w/e)
GTA IV - Saints Row 2
MGS4 - Splinter Cell (the one coming soonish forgot the name).
Uncharted 2 - Tomb Raider (the newest one lol).
Gears of war 2 - Quantum Theory
Street Fighter IV(?) - Tekken 6
Assassin's Creed II - Prince of Persia - Arkham Asylum
Lego Star Wars - Lego Batman
All the CODs I've played: COD4 - MW2

[Neil]

Some of those comparisons are just dumb, Viva Pinata is nothing like Mario or LBP.

The lego games shouldn't of even been included in this because they're all reskins of "Lego The Game" or something and Assassins Creed was born because of PoP, you know both having the same publishers and probably developers and all.

While BFBC2 is nothing like MW2, if anything it should be compared to Massive Action Failure.

GTA4 compared against Saints Row is the only non-dumb one in that whole list really.

[Black_Apalachi]

... GTA4 compared against Saints Row is the only non-dumb one in that whole list really.

And even then, I see Saints Row as just a huge fail-rip of GTA lol

[Neil]

And even then, I see Saints Row as just a huge fail-rip of GTA lol

Na as far as comparisons go it actually makes sense, personally I think Saints Row is far better than GTA4, while you may be able to do all those boring things GTA offers, Saints Row offers none of that but does let you drive a septic truck and shoot garbage at buildings, definitely more fun.

[Stitch]

MW2
Heavy Rain
Killzone 2
Littlebigplanet
GTA IV
MGS4
Uncharted 2
Gears of war 2
Street Fighter IV(?) <-> Tekken 6 - No idea I hardly play fighting games
Arkham Asylum
Lego Star Wars
CoD2

[PaulMacC]

Some of those comparisons are just dumb, Viva Pinata is nothing like Mario or LBP.

The lego games shouldn't of even been included in this because they're all reskins of "Lego The Game" or something and Assassins Creed was born because of PoP, you know both having the same publishers and probably developers and all.

While BFBC2 is nothing like MW2, if anything it should be compared to Massive Action Failure.

GTA4 compared against Saints Row is the only non-dumb one in that whole list really.
This plus no RPGs, lolwut?

[dbgtz]

I don't know many RPGs and like i said, they're either best compared or most generally compared. Theres no need to get your knickers in a twist.

Also you can still compare LEGO stories lol.

[Fez]

Stories in a LEGO game?

HA.

I trust you mean 'brand', well, there's no real 'ultimate' game, it's all personal preference on the brand.

[AlexOC]

MW2
Heavy Rain
Killzone 2Red Steel 2
Littlebigplanet
Saints Row 2
MGS4
Uncharted 2
Gears of war 2
Tekken 6
Assassin's Creed II
Lego Batman
MW2 (the only cod ive ever had)