Which necklace?

[JACKTARD]

Had a look at some necklaces for my girlfriend for valentines day, I'm not really sure which one to get so thought I'd get the opinions from you lovely people :P

If you don't like either then say why and if you could post another one then I'd be grateful :)

http://s7ondemand4.scene7.com/is/image/Signet/8431590?$detail$


http://s7ondemand4.scene7.com/is/image/Signet/8190275?$detail$

[Chris]

I like the top one best, the second one is too...flashy? 0.o

[benjamin]

does she like bling or not? after that maybe you shall have your answer.

[JACKTARD]

hmm yeah i suppose the bottom one is a bit too tacky :l.

Think the top one is nice though? Knowing me I'll probably buy it and it'll be rank

[Nicola]

The top one is really nice, a much nicer design than the bottom one.

[benjamin]

yeah the top one is nice, it's the one i prefer anyway.

[lawrawrrr]

love the top one! lucky girl ;)

[Jacob]

The bottom one looks more special! The top one looks like something cheap you could buy from a market.

[matt$]

The bottom one looks more special! The top one looks like something cheap you could buy from a market.

depends how it feels in your hand i guess, if its extremely light i'd skip it and yeah the 2nd one looks a bit tacky