Nazi, age 98, is charged for War Crimes

[Negativities]

BUDAPEST (Reuters) - Hungarian prosecutors on Tuesday charged a 98-year-old man who tops the Nazi-hunting Simon Wiesenthal Center's wanted list with war crimes, saying he had helped to deport Jews to Auschwitz in World War Two.
Laszlo Csatary was found guilty in absentia in 1948 of whipping or torturing Jews and helping to deport them to the death camp while serving as police commander in the Nazi-occupied eastern Slovak city of Kosice in 1944.

He was charged on death, and was on the run until Hungarian authorities finally found and retrieved him.


What's your opinion on this story?

Story can be found here:
http://news.yahoo.com/hungarian-man-98-charged-world-war-ii-crimes-080153598.html

http://l2.yimg.com/bt/api/res/1.2/oQr9Qg4NkktOMFoh1bykOA--/YXBwaWQ9eW5ld3M7Y2g9MzQ4O2NyPTE7Y3c9NDUwO2R4PTA7ZH k9MDtmaT11bGNyb3A7aD0zNDg7cT04NTt3PTQ1MA--/http://media.zenfs.com/en_us/News/Reuters/2013-06-18T080153Z_1_CBRE95H0MBB00_RTROPTP_2_HUNGARY-WARCRIMES.JPG

[God]

Dont matter what you've done, it will always catch up to you sometime in life.

[Negativities]

Dont matter what you've done, it will always catch up to you sometime in life.


I was thinking the same. I didn't know whether to feel bad because he has been in hiding his whole life and most officers were forced to do these things to live.

However, this man now seeks retirement in hell.

[Ardemax]

I was thinking the same. I didn't know whether to feel bad because he has been in hiding his whole life and most officers were forced to do these things to live.

However, this man now seeks retirement in hell.

And most officers did it for personal gain.

Either way he has to pay for his crimes but it is unlikely he will go to jail given his condition.

[e5]

What's the point?
He's 98 and lived his life lol :S

[-:Undertaker:-]

Good news, justice should be pursued.

[Cerys]

Yeah it's all good that the law is doing its job, but it's a bit stupid to make him spend his last moments etc *given his age I expect he doesn't have that long?* in jail..

Idk.

It's good that they were still looking for him all these years later. xD

[-:Undertaker:-]

Yeah it's all good that the law is doing its job, but it's a bit stupid to make him spend his last moments etc *given his age I expect he doesn't have that long?* in jail..

Idk.

It's good that they were still looking for him all these years later. xD

He's lucky he's even alive to even experience 'those last moments' - unlike his victims. A part of his punishment will be spending these last moments of his life in prison, and if you are a religious person alike myself (believing in an afterlife) you'll also believe that his punishment will continue after death when he meets his creator. That's justice.

Moors murderer Ian Brady is in his 70s now, should he be allowed out because he looks like a nice, caring old man? certainly not.

[Cerys]

He's lucky he's even alive to even experience 'those last moments' - unlike his victims. A part of his punishment will be spending these last moments of his life in prison, and if you are a religious person alike myself (believing in an afterlife) you'll also believe that his punishment will continue after death when he meets his creator.

Moors murderer Ian Brady is in his 70s now, should he be allowed out because he looks like a nice, caring old man? certainly not.


Well to be honest, Ian Brady is mentally ill so he should be kept there. Clearly.
I never said he SHOULDN'T go to jail for it, so stop accusing me of that, all I'm saying is that it's pointless.

[-:Undertaker:-]

Well to be honest, Ian Brady is mentally ill so he should be kept there. Clearly.
I never said he SHOULDN'T go to jail for it, so stop accusing me of that, all I'm saying is that it's pointless.

The punishing of crimes, in this case a heinous crime, is pointless? Justice aka punishment is what a justice system is founded on.

[Cerys]

The punishing of crimes, in this case a heinous crime, is pointless? Justice aka punishment is what a justice system is founded on.

... You're twisting my words okay. This is why I hate discussing with you ;;;;;;

What I mean by pointless is that he has a very short time to live, so it'd be a waste of space/time/money to put him away. Surely another form of punishment would be more appropriate. Perhaps put him in a secure unit which isn't as brutal as a jail.

[MKR&*42]

The courts might let him off cause of his age, but he still deserves a sentence. If someone murders X amount of people and they're not caught until 50 years later, you don't go "Oh it's in the past it's fine" do you? It was still a crime and he still deserves punishment for it regardless of his age :S

[Chippiewill]

Sums up my thoughts pretty well:

"Csatáry was a small fish. I could name 2,000 people responsible for worse crimes than he was. The money spent hunting down people like him would be better spent fighting the propaganda of those who so energetically deny the Holocaust today."
László Karsai

[cornbix]

Kill him! Torturing, whipping... Ugh! Evil nasty peasant! Get cancer rat.

[Kardan]

He should serve time if there's enough evidence of his crime, which there seems to be. Age should be no factor.

Well done for bringing this up though, when I saw this on the news, I thought it would be a good debate :)

[karter]

What's the point when he has lived his life and is about to die?? Shouldn't punish him in my opinion

[Ardemax]

Sums up my thoughts pretty well:

László Karsai

I thought it was only inbreds who still deny the Holocaust?


Kill him! Torturing, whipping... Ugh! Evil nasty peasant! Get cancer rat.

Hope there is sarcasm in this.


Age should be no factor.


Shouldn't punish him in my opinion

What Kardan said ^

[Daltron]

Age is no excuse for the law.

[GommeInc]

Got mixed thoughts about this. It seems like justice was served cold by being brought out too late. He's lived his life, unlike his victims. Would prison really be justifiable? It seems all too little for too late.