Best songwriters... EVER

[Loui]

Well another thread has provoked me to make this un'

So who do you think is the best songwriters ever...

I'ma post mine when I decide k.

[Thrilled]

Well first off, there's a difference between Best Songwriters and Best Lyricists. For example Axl Rose was a great songwriter, just not a very good lyricist. So don't get mixed up people. My top 5 songwriters of all time:

1. John Lennon/Paul McCartney - (The Beatles)
2. Mick Jagger/Keith Richards - (Rolling Stones)
3. Bob Dylan
4. Pete Townshend - (The Who)
5. Brian Wilson - (Beach Boys)

[Loui]

Yuss I was also thinking along the lines of Lennon & McCartney

[Code]

Hmm, Lennon- Imagine'd be one. Young/Young/Scott were good (AC/DC).

Yeah.

~Code

[Tom H]

Im more of a classical Music Person.

here are my thoughts:

1.Haydn- trumpet concerto in EFlat Major
2.Bach - Tocatto in D Minor
3.Goff Richards- Celtic knots
4. Beethoven - fur Elise

Regards

Tom

[RedStratocas]

John Lennon, Kurt Cobain, and Chris Cornell had the best work. Chris Cornell's lyrics I love, because many songs are like stories.

[NekkLe]

Noel Galager - Oasis

[Victimized]

Brandon Boyd
Zack De La Rocha
Anthony Kiedis

[kaut]

Bob Dylan/John Lennon/Kurt Cobain

[Not-Thrilled]

Brandon Boyd
Zack De La Rocha

Zack and Brandon were great lyricists, not too greater songwriters Imo. Cobain was a great songwriter but there are lots better than him.

[Rashelly]

I personally think Kurt Cobain was and still is OH so overrated - but that's my opinion.
My top LYRICISTS would be:
Jeff Buckley - wow, his music is so...wow...
John Lennon - I think more so than Paul McCartney, but again, my opinion
Bob Dylan - again, incredible
Kris Roe (frontman for The Ataris) - This is for personal reasons, a lot of his songs (I know this sound cheesy) sometimes just make me cry (how sad is that)

[Not-Thrilled]

I personally think Kurt Cobain was and still is OH so overrated - but that's my opinion.


I think Nirvana were over-rated and his guitar playing is as well. But not his lyrical/songwriting ability. As a lyricist he's up there with 90's stars such as Vedder and Maynard James Keenan (Tool). He's my idol so I'm probably slightly biased. He was able to do so much with his songs and there was always an underlying meaning involved. On a personal level, he was great to listen to, especially when depressed. It's like he understands how you feel, because his songs contain so much emotion and subtle or explosive bursts of anger.

On a lyrical basis, I think In Utero was one of the greatest albums of our generation. There's so much meaning involved with every song, only a genius could write so imaginably. As a guitar player, he is often very over-rated. I remember Rolling Stone magazine put him at #10 on the all-time greatest guitarists' list. After reading that article, I lost all respect I ever had for that magazine. Sure, Cobain was a very good guitar player, but nothing special. He didn't revolutionise playing or anything else similar, he could just create average riffs. I think his death, as usual with rockstars, has improved his popularity as millions portray him as a god-like figure.

[Rashelly]

On a lyrical basis, I think In Utero was one of the greatest albums of our generation.
I think his death, as usual with rockstars, has improved his popularity as millions portray him as a god-like figure.
[/color][/size][/font]
Actually I would agree with you there, on both points.

[RedStratocas]

Yeh, I agree that nirvana and his guitar playing were over rated, but there are reasons why. Obviously SLTS was the kickstart for alternative. There werent many [good] alternative bands before, and around the time of nirvana's popularity boom. Everyone loved the sound, but there were very few bands that made it. Kinda my theory... I agree though, over rated as a whole, still love em though.

Ok, might sound stupid, but Gavin Rossdale of Bush/institute. He probably has the wierdest lyrics that at some times dont even make sense, but it gets you thinking about what he means, or what he is actually saying. Kind of like paintings, no one wants to look at something they have seen before, but wierd ones always gets your attention.

[Jim Rotates]

Ok, might sound stupid, but Gavin Rossdale of Bush/institute. He probably has the wierdest lyrics that at some times dont even make sense, but it gets you thinking about what he means, or what he is actually saying. Kind of like paintings, no one wants to look at something they have seen before, but wierd ones always gets your attention.

Oh yeh, everytime I listen to Swallowed when he sings "In the middle of the world on a fish hook, you're the wave you're the wave you're the wave" It get's me thinking about it for a while...

[Victimized]

Omar Rodriquez Lopex/Cedric Bixler out of At The Drive In/ Mars Volta. Seriously amazing, i put both because they alternate songwriting duties and i love all their songs so yeah.

http://www.adressa.no/multimedia/archive/00533/MarsVolta2_533292f.jpg

AND

Daryll Palumbo from Head Automatica/Glassjaw. This guy is amazing suffers from Crohn's disease and his lyrics are just full of so much emotion. It kinda makes me feel like i should stop complaining and imagine being in his shoes.

http://imgs.idnes.cz/hudba/A050323_KOT_HEADAUTOMATICA_V.JPG

[beth]

Bert McCracken of The Used writes such great lyrics.
Most of them are based on the times he spent in Utah while he used to do drugs etc. They are really emotional and yah ;] I love the guy.

[Victimized]

And Adam Lazzara from Taking Back Sunday

[beth]

And Adam Lazzara from Taking Back Sunday


^^^ Yahhh! TBS have some of the best lyrics everrr