Layout Prefer

Which layout do you prefer?

this one:
http://www.sparkload.com/uploads/acc43-Template.bmp

or this one:

http://www.sparkload.com/uploads/41d43-Template2.bmp

The top of the seccond one, with the red dots in each corner, would be an iframe with a marquee going across the page with latest updates.
The white boxes with purple dots are content boxes
and right at the bottom, with cyan dots,would be a marquee with the Habbo disclaimer.

Which do you prefer, and why?
C+C please.

Note: the dots obviously won't be on the finished design

the top one.

Neither to be honest, but top if I had to pick.

Thanks Scott :)
Thanks Despect :)

+Rep

Rep returned if I can :D

The first one

The first one, although it has wayyyyyyy too much shading.

Neither, but if I had to pick, the first one.
Also - save as png not bmp.