It sucks now, there's no point for it, if everytime someone reports a pointless -rep even when its valid. It gets approved and removed.
This isn't a poxy happy hospital, negative & positive things should be treated equally.
Printable View
It sucks now, there's no point for it, if everytime someone reports a pointless -rep even when its valid. It gets approved and removed.
This isn't a poxy happy hospital, negative & positive things should be treated equally.
I agreeeeeee. Even if the rep is pointless, it still indicates that someone isn't so fond of you, meaning your reputation is actually lowered anyway. idno.
I don't believe any rep ought to be removed, whether positive or negative. Some guy just doesn't like you? That's a hit on your reputation. Someone got your back in an argument about potatoes? Doesn't matter how stupid it is, that's a boost to your reputation. The entire point of such a system was and still ought to be a form of user moderation, being forced to pretend that everyone gets on has damaged that but removing negative rep is also a step in the wrong direction.
Reputation is reputation. It is not a currency, so someone lowering your score by 2 points isn't stealing anything from you, it's just showing your loss of social esteem.
Why isn't reputation just removed completely o_O It's pointless.
it's been like that ever since i remember except you used to get your +rep off too
i bet you have more pointless +rep than -rep anyway
I like -rep, I hardly ever use it. And when I get -rep I never report it, (well, I have never got -repped for a pointless reason) they have all be fair to me.
Rep isn't pointless, it highlights that someone has either done something to a good standard e.g. a graphic, or say a poorly alted .jpeg image etc.
Someone -repped me ages ago when I did a rubbish recolour thing, I found it kinda harsh since I was quite new and just trying out something new, but I kept it anyway. :PQuote:
Originally Posted by David Jason
I think the reputation system is alright really. It's been like it for so long and there's never really been any problems. Yes, a lot of people do report their reputation and it gets removed, however I think that this isn't always the case. I still have quite a few! I think -rep can be used in some situations for it's actual purpose and when it's used properly it makes sense to have it- it's just when people abuse it- it becomes the problem.
I think the "Report Reputation Problems" thread should stay, but brandon should take a small little investigation if you get me, cos I agree with you that people report it because they've got a -rep, not because it is pointless.
I've had a few -reps and I think around 5 have been pointless and 3 haven't. I only report rep when I feel that it needs to be reported, so I have 3 -reps on my plate because they were fair, the other 5? I reported them, they were removed and I think they were fair. However, I have -repped some times (I actually don't do it that much) and people have reported it (cos I know the approx. time unless it was coincidence hehe) and I would deem it as fair. I think some people need to just live that their post was bad or whatever and that's that. Therefore, to try and put this post back onto a point, I believe -rep should stay, but it's far more "difficult" to remove. Also, I think brandon should do a 2 line PM (I know, piling the work on him, sorry! :() if it hasn't been removed explaining. This prevents "OMG HE JUST IS BEING LAZY!!!" and stuff. Also, I'm sure there are people who report -rep and have pointless +reps (I'm assuming but I would say the probability is rather high). I think these should be looked into as well throughout the last month because it's not fair getting rid of a pointless -rep without the +rep which is pointless going.
I'm tired, sorry if I'm talking crap.
-rep should stay.
I only report -rep if it was things like 'learn to spell' or 'haha i hate you' - if you are going to -rep a post you should leave a clear reason why.
If you remove -rep you might as well remove rep completely.
For example my first ever two reps were both minus. They were:
- You are the biggest noob ever.
- Get a new habbo name.
If I got those now I would report them - as they have nothing to do with my post. Whereas I have had some for being rude - which is fair.
I think that example is perfectly fine. Your grammar and spelling affects your reputation and what others think of you.Quote:
Originally Posted by Milestone