(Before you start answering bare in mind this is probably unrealistic)
I've heard different answers for both of these and I thought it would be a good idea to see what other people say. http://i.imgur.com/ttIcjD8.png
Scenario 1) Two people (A and B in this case) were both involved in a accident. Both, some how, have both got the same injuries. A and B are very different. A is a male, 27 years of age and has no one to go to (if he survives), he had dropped out of college and never went back. He is fairly unhealthy for his age. B is a female, 69 :cool: years old and has a lovely supportive family and loads of friends to go to (if she survives) she is healthy for her age.
The only problem is that you have to move one person, since it'd be impossible to operate like this. If you move one, the one who has been moved will die (and vice versa)
How do you choose who lives and who dies?
Scenario 2) Exactly the same profiles but both are suffering different injuries. A has internal bleeding, so he'll probably die if they don't hurry up. Where as B can not feel below her waist, but her operation will be risky as well. And the same problem is that if you move one, they die.
How do you choose who lives and who dies?
my answers:
s1) Probably the female in this case. I say this because she'd have more of a supportive group around her than the male.
s2) Probably the male, he will probably live a good life compared to the elderly woman
ok enjoy ;l
13-05-2013, 07:01 AM
Empired
69 is old enough, she has lived a good life already and letting her live would just be a waste. She would probably be gone in 20 years maximum anyway
think this for both situations
and i would lie to her family and say there was no way of saving her
13-05-2013, 09:03 AM
karter
s1 as i sympathize more with women especially the elderly
s2 probably the man
13-05-2013, 09:07 AM
Kardan
If that did happen, I wouldn't be the one to decide who to save, I'd go get help. But if I had to pick, I'd pick the guy on both occasions.
13-05-2013, 09:30 AM
Daltron
id pick the guy on both occassions..
This scenario totally reminds me of the scene from the gore/horror movie SAW where they have to kill one person from a selction to move on and they have different backgrounds and blah blah, if anyone has seen the movies you will know what I am talking about haha.
13-05-2013, 10:28 AM
MKR&*42
Male in both cases although Idek why... Just sympathise with men lately
13-05-2013, 11:23 AM
Zelda
Woman in first, considering I'm sure the guy would probably be considering comitting anyway or at least won't enjoy life, while the woman has a lot of family who care about her that it'd hurt.
In second the guy probably as being younger he'd most likely be likelier to survive and there could be a lot of complications for the woman which wouldn't be great at her age.
In reality I don't think is make the choice tho would get someone else too cause would be too hard and devastating
13-05-2013, 11:59 AM
geo
i'd wanna know a bit more about them than that ;| don't think i'd like to pick life or death but going with this... i'd save the guy in s1 and s2
13-05-2013, 12:59 PM
Yawn
save lady both times man sounds gd for nothing
13-05-2013, 02:22 PM
Succubus
Quote:
Originally Posted by Daltron
id pick the guy on both occassions..
This scenario totally reminds me of the scene from the gore/horror movie SAW where they have to kill one person from a selction to move on and they have different backgrounds and blah blah, if anyone has seen the movies you will know what I am talking about haha.
The one with the barbed wire? if so then yes aha, I kinda based it on that + a scene from grey's
Quote:
Originally Posted by Inkwell
Woman in first, considering I'm sure the guy would probably be considering comitting anyway or at least won't enjoy life, while the woman has a lot of family who care about her that it'd hurt.
In second the guy probably as being younger he'd most likely be likelier to survive and there could be a lot of complications for the woman which wouldn't be great at her age.
In reality I don't think is make the choice tho would get someone else too cause would be too hard and devastating
yeah, could look up if there has been any cases like this hm
Quote:
Originally Posted by mcdonalds
i'd wanna know a bit more about them than that ;| don't think i'd like to pick life or death but going with this... i'd save the guy in s1 and s2
the man is ugly and the woman is a resemblance to dana delany
