Halal - Right or Wrong?

dosent matter to me, as long as the animal doesnt suffer, and in this case the animal didnt suffer.

ive seen a sheep get killed and prepared the halal way.

Well I didn't know, why has it never been used as an execution technique, it'd certainly be cheap?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Virgin Mary

Well I didn't know, why has it never been used as an execution technique, it'd certainly be cheap?

---

Well it wouldn't be classed as humane due to all the blood and the minute of pain. There is similar method's though, the guillotine and beheading being two, neither are really used these days much, certainly not in the West.

Guilotine and beheading do the same job :)

So why don't they behead the animal?

Personally I want to know what was involved in the study of finding out if it causes the animal pain. There is no way that they can know for sure if the animal is in pain or not.

I think allot of people use 'scientific proof' as a way of getting around things. The average person has no knowledge on these scientific studies and therefore has no reason to question it, this leads to people believing what they say and they get to continue killing in this inhumane way.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Everlong

Personally I want to know what was involved in the study of finding out if it causes the animal pain. There is no way that they can know for sure if the animal is in pain or not.

I think allot of people use 'scientific proof' as a way of getting around things. The average person has no knowledge on these scientific studies and therefore has no reason to question it, this leads to people believing what they say and they get to continue killing in this inhumane way.

---

If the animal cries.

I dont see a major problem of killing an animal in this way as if the animal is caused pain then it is not for a prolonged period it is for a very short time and the reason why the animal has its throat slit is because they want to have respect for the animal. People eat battery chickens who have had a much worse life then a Halal free range chicken which has had a good life.

althoguh it may be disrespectful to ban it in our country, they have turned our country into aan over pollitically correct country that we cant even air our vieews on what their religion does.

I see no reason why a charge to the head cannot be done before slitting the throats and letting them drain. If anyone saw kill it cook it eat it then you will know what i mean

It's a religious tradtition of Islam, banning Halal meat would basically be denying all people of Muslim faith to eat meat which i think is wrong.