"Report reputation thread"

Nah, I agree with you 100%. I -repped someone who had insulted me. His post even got edited by a moderator so surely that's more than a valid reason to -rep yet it was removed. I was going to make a very similar thread to this later today because I've noticed this too.

I +rep posts that are constructive and helpful to me. I -rep posts that are rude and unnecessary. OK, some of mine deserve to be removed, admittedly. However, the thread as of late is basically used for people to get their -rep removed when really some of the -rep that has been removed is valid.

I've already been in contact with MattGarner about this but he told me to PM nvrspk4. I just haven't got around to it yet. I agree with you totally and things need to be reviewed. I can understand how the system is supposed to work, getting revenge and pointless rep removed but at the present time it isn't working like that.

I have 2 thats brandon would not remove because i insulted the person and it was valid.

Lol Ye
It Was
Just Being
A Thicko
And Cba
To Find
It At
The Time
:)

Just because it's posted in that thread it doesn't necessarily mean it was removed.

That's the problem though Garion. That is generally what is happening. Not always no - but the majority yes. OK, some may be pointless but I know for a fact valid -reps are being removed too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Immenseman

That's the problem though Garion. That is generally what is happening. Not always no - but the majority yes. OK, some may be pointless but I know for a fact valid -reps are being removed too.

---

You know for a fact?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nvrspk4

You know for a fact?

---

FO SHO FOR A FACT!

But tbh, just be careful what you leave on the comment.

Ye, if the comment isnt valid or the point on which the rep was given then it does get removed and alot of the time they are left there too.

I remember, I reported a -rep once and at the same time the old admin who dealt with it was Nick- and he removed over 600 rep points from old Alkaz which were invalid, so they do do their jobs :)

its easy to tell though, if u -rep someone and you see them report it and then try to rep them within a week.. You can tell if it has been removed.

yup, for a fact.