Lol this was a great analogy! :D
I think the only reason this'd be a good idea is because of when you win a competition/event your rep doesn't increase with a comment (even though comps do those PMs now) but otherwise like Gomme said it's a bit OCD. After all, it doesn't matter if it's FlyingJesus giving the rep or some noob like Mathew (:P), rep is given for the right reasons most of the time.

