Is fish meat?

not sure

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Oleh

You never have fish at a carvery, because it isn't meat :)

---

I never have horse either. Or duck. And I never see lamb either :(

- - - Updated - - -

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kyle

I don't class fish as meat cos to me meat is fatty n fish aint

also wouldnt eat a cow whole but could eat a fish whole

diff things go away

---

Pics or it didn't happen.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kardan

I never have horse either. Or duck. And I never see lamb either :(

- - - Updated - - -



Pics or it didn't happen.

---

After the horse meat scandal who really knows whether you've had horse at a carvery or not ;)

I understand your point d.w. :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kuybii

Nail on the head;
Birds = Meat
Fish = Meat
Cattle = Meat

Fish is just a classification of the word meat. Perfect example is when your on an aeroplane and the lovely orange hostess offers you fish, meat or veggie. You couldn't say yeah we have, meat, meat and the veggie option.

---

then why would they not just offer you meat or the veggie option without saying the extra meat? if everyone recognised fish as meat then there wouldn't be any need to say fish, right?

fish is technically meat yes, but if someone asked me what meat I wanted I wouldn't presume fish is included in the options because people just say fish if they mean fish???

well theres diff types of meat
red meat
white meat
Fish
& things like bugs (voms)

they're all technically meat just... different branches of it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hollie

then why would they not just offer you meat or the veggie option without saying the extra meat? if everyone recognised fish as meat then there wouldn't be any need to say fish, right?

---

But how would fillis, our lovely orange hostess get across to you what she intends on serving? If she is offering chicken, fish and a veggie option, how would she determine which meats they are without stating their names?

Its like saying chewing gum, chocolate bars and skittles aren't confectionary. They're all different individual items but yet they would still fall under the confectionary category. Just like fish, chicken, pork. All totally different types of meat, but still all come under the same category as meat.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kuybii

But how would fillis, our lovely orange hostess get across to you what she intends on serving? If she is offering chicken, fish and a veggie option, how would she determine which meats they are without stating their names?

Its like saying chewing gum, chocolate bars and skittles aren't confectionary. They're all different individual items but yet they would still fall under the confectionary category. Just like fish, chicken, pork. All totally different types of meat, but still all come under the same category as meat.

---

saying chicken, fish and the veggie option is stating a name though. the same applies to meat as it does for fish, you'd still have to say what type of fish it is just like you'd have to say what type of meat it is. regardless of whether you said meat (including fish) + the veggie option or fish, meat or the veggie option, you'd still need to expand further and be more specific.

yeah I agree with your second point, I wasn't arguing that fish isn't technically meat. people would still say 'would you like some chocolate?' rather than 'would you like some confectionery?'. same can be applied to meat/fish :P

I'd say it is meat yeah

Animal is meat.
Fish is animal.
Fish is meat.