Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Contains spoilers

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

03-08-2009, 01:13 PM
Santorefish

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jordan:A

I read the book, its a totally different ending to the film.

And I dont want to watch the next couple because

hagrid dies

It was quite good actually, some people were saying it was crap

according to the books hagrid does not die
08-08-2009, 10:21 PM
Devestation

and yet;

fred/george dies, AND DOBBY

I cant believe in the next book

nagani kills snape, ima cry at that
08-08-2009, 10:24 PM
Kardan

I'm so angry at the film :( It felt rushed. If you haven't read the book you wouldn't know what was going on. There was no emphasise on the HBP at all except for one potions scene. There were so many mistakes in the film (such as Harry having the locket within the cave, yet Dumbledore having it after the Astronomy Tower scene).

Pah. I thought it was the funniest film, and I thought it was much better than OOTP. But not the best. I'm glad DH is being split into two, hopefully it won't seem as rushed.
08-08-2009, 10:33 PM
Blinger1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Devestation

and yet;

fred/george dies, AND DOBBY

I cant believe in the next book

nagani kills snape, ima cry at that

Are you going to cry when Hedwig dies too?
08-08-2009, 10:40 PM
Laggings

The 6th movie was just terrible. The only part with real action was when the hand reached out of the water and grabbed him. Was LOL when half the theater jumped up and screamed. But besides that, it contains maybe 1/20th of what was in the book.

3/10 GF movie.
09-08-2009, 03:33 PM
Neversoft

I found it enjoyable, but to be honest it wasn't very good. Fair enough, Hermione x Ron but Harry x Ginny? Where was the development for that? Suddenly they're in love with each other? Since when? What happened to Cho? Was she even in the movie? I assume they haven't adapted the book very well.

I liked the fact that the movie had very little action when compared to the others. It seemed like it was actually focusing on the characters for once. I also found myself laughing quite a few times throughout, especially when Harry took that potion and at small things like Harry and Ron fighting for the book. Scenes come and go like bullet trains though and although the movie was quite long, it needed to be longer. It needs more development. Also, looking back at all the Harry Potter films thus far... theres a lot of stuff I still don't get... and a lot of things I think are just plain stupid. I hope the last films can explain a few things and end it on a good note.

I couldn't help but make a mental note that the scene just after Snape killed Dumbledore, where he was falling off the building, plummeting to the floor, needed to be longer to have any impact. His death seemed to be over too fast. One second Dumbledore's falling, the next Harry's having a chat with Snape, then the next everyones holding up their wands like lighters as if to say "Rock on, Dumbledoor!" That sequence didn't really work...

The thing the really annoys me though is the fact that Luna got so little screen time. She's the best character but she's hardly in the movie. She only has a few lines. That's unforgivable. Even when Harry took her to the dinner party she was in one scene then he just ditched her and she was never to be seen again. I'm sure I read something a while ago saying that in one of the books, I'm assuming The Half-Blood Prince, she does a live commentary for a game of Quidditch. Where the hell was that in the movie? I demand adequate screen time for Luna in both parts of The Deathly Hallows or else.
09-08-2009, 03:41 PM
jackass

Quote:

Originally Posted by Devestation

and yet;

fred/george dies, AND DOBBY

I cant believe in the next book

nagani kills snape, ima cry at that

Highly unlikely that Dobby will even be in the next film, or Kreacher, as neither of them were in this one.
09-08-2009, 03:44 PM
Kardan

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neversoft

I found it enjoyable, but to be honest it wasn't very good. Fair enough, Hermione x Ron but Harry x Ginny? Where was the development for that? Suddenly they're in love with each other? Since when? What happened to Cho? Was she even in the movie? I assume they haven't adapted the book very well.

I liked the fact that the movie had very little action when compared to the others. It seemed like it was actually focusing on the characters for once. I also found myself laughing quite a few times throughout, especially when Harry took that potion and at small things like Harry and Ron fighting for the book. Scenes come and go like bullet trains though and although the movie was quite long, it needed to be longer. It needs more development. Also, looking back at all the Harry Potter films thus far... theres a lot of stuff I still don't get... and a lot of things I think are just plain stupid. I hope the last films can explain a few things and end it on a good note.

I couldn't help but make a mental note that the scene just after Snape killed Dumbledore, where he was falling off the building, plummeting to the floor, needed to be longer to have any impact. His death seemed to be over too fast. One second Dumbledore's falling, the next Harry's having a chat with Snape, then the next everyones holding up their wands like lighters as if to say "Rock on, Dumbledoor!" That sequence didn't really work...

The thing the really annoys me though is the fact that Luna got so little screen time. She's the best character but she's hardly in the movie. She only has a few lines. That's unforgivable. Even when Harry took her to the dinner party she was in one scene then he just ditched her and she was never to be seen again. I'm sure I read something a while ago saying that in one of the books, I'm assuming The Half-Blood Prince, she does a live commentary for a game of Quidditch. Where the hell was that in the movie? I demand adequate screen time for Luna in both parts of The Deathly Hallows or else.

Luna should get more screentime in DH as they visit her house for information no the Deathly Hallows :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Biohazard

Highly unlikely that Dobby will even be in the next film, or Kreacher, as neither of them were in this one.

Dobby is in the film as scenes have been filmed where:

Dobby gets buried.
09-08-2009, 03:46 PM
jackass

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kardan

Dobby is in the film as scenes have been filmed where:

Dobby gets buried.

:O Oh right!

Glad about that! :D

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince *Contains spoilers*

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Contains spoilers