Printable View
A lot of plot holes to be honest.
River song is technically not a murderer as the time travelling justice squad saw the entire story essentially so why was she imprisoned.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chippiewill
If she doesn't know his name yet then what did she whisper to tennant in Silence in the Library where they first met in his timeline.
how does the girl that is blatantly a young Melody Pond tie in with the rest of the story.
They had to pretend so everyone would think the doctor died.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jin
His name... He could have told her his name in the last 200 years which we missed. They did a lot of stuff then...
The girl in the spacesuit? It's just what happened to river as a kid. Where the silence kept her, how the spacesuit came about and such
It all went downhill after Eccleston left. You actually believed that The Doctor was this thing of myth across the universe, and they turned him into a joke. They turned it into a kids tv show, which it never was.
Now all the Doctors look like skinny emo-kids and solves every episode by seemingly pressing a button or the overuse of the screwdriver.
Big dissapointment, it had so much potential. Robert Carlyle for the next Doctor (as he was touted before they unveiled that woeful runt Matt Smith), he will actually bring a darker side to the whole thing, rather than laughing off mass genocide, the eccentric thing is running a bit thin now.
And a another thing, who actually found the whole River Song a big meander for nothing. It was cringe-worthy when you saw this middle-aged old queen try and pretend to be mysterious and sexy. Boo.
Oh god, Robert Carlyle would be such a cool doctor.
I don't think they were on the teselator at the time.Quote:
River song is technically not a murderer as the time travelling justice squad saw the entire story essentially so why was she imprisoned.
She finds out his name a bit later in her timeline.Quote:
If she doesn't know his name yet then what did she whisper to tennant in Silence in the Library where they first met in his timeline.
Posting 'Doctor Who and Me 5' at the weekend; my thoughts on this Series and Torchwood and general Who.
Probably elaborate on the whole "Watching next series" or not.
Gonna mention DWC?Quote:
Originally Posted by Fez
Maybe. I was considering going through my boxsets and doing a complete overview for a 'Doctor Who and Me 6'.Quote:
Originally Posted by dbgtz
Might just do a little overview.
Got this today, emailed him like 3 weeks ago
http://i52.tinypic.com/213n8y.jpg
While we're all entitled to an opinion, I have to disagree with... Mostly everything.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hett
While I agree that it has become more child-friendly especially since Matt Smith, it was always intended as a family show.
Series one IMO is the worst season. Besides a few episodes, it was pretty bad.
The Doctor isn't supposed to be dark... It's the newer series (ie not classic) that tried to give him some depth. I'd also say that most Doctors have been eccentric... No point in stopping that now.
The Doctor does have to be eccentric yes, and while I'm a big fan of Matt Smith, I do think they need to sit back and write better storylines for him. All this Silence stuff is all well and good, but it's all solved in the episodes far too quickly, and there's never a sense that the Doctor might actually be defeated.