Charlie and the chocolate factory

Anyone seen the new one with JDepp in it?

If so, what one do you think is better, The original, or new one?

ORIGINAL!

I prefer the new one xP and meh, i really should of put a poll ><

old one . U can't beat the classics

Johnny Depp isnt a comedy actor. Someone like Rowan Atkinson, or Ben Stiller would have played it better.

Old one ftw. I just think the acting is better etc.

I like the new one :D
I dont like Jonny Depp but he pulls it off amazingly.

The old one.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hecktix

Johnny Depp isnt a comedy actor. Someone like Rowan Atkinson, or Ben Stiller would have played it better.

---

Or Jim Carey?

The old one.

The umpa lumpas just ruin the new one:rolleyes:

both are good, i prefer the new one though because the start of the old one is well boring it takes too long to get into the actual factory.