Your Team/Player Ratings For FIFA 10

I've made this thread to see what everyone thinks their team ratings may be, and what they think other player and team ratings may be for FIFA 10. :)

Manchester City - Four Star Team

GK
Given - 84
Taylor - 79
Hart - 80 (loan)

DEF
Richards - 78
Zabaleta - 79
Toure - 81
Dunne - 79
Lescott - 80 (if the deal is going to be completed lol)
Onouha - 80
Bridge - 79
Sylvinho - 76
Garrido - 73
Logan - 71 (loan)
Ben-Haim - 74

CDM
Barry - 82
Kompany - 80

MID
De Jong - 79
Wright-Phillips - 80
Ireland - 83
Robinho - 84
Petrov - 79
Weiss - 72
Etuhu - 70 (loan)
McDermott 69 (loan)
Johnson - 76

ATK
Adebayour - 84
Tevez - 84
Santa Cruz - 79
Bellamy - 78
Caicedo - 76 (loan)
Jo - 74 (loan)
Bojinov - 76 (loan)
Benjani - 76


My views on some of the best players in the world.

Kaka - 89
Ronaldo - 90
Villa - 87
Ribery - 88
Messi - 89
Torres - 86
Lampard - 87
Gerrard - 87

You'll be four and a half atleast. :S

I reckon we'll be 3 and a half, maybe pushing four.

Jones - 80/1
Bent - 78
Cattermole - 76
Cana - 78
Malbranque and Richardson around 75
Da Silva - 74

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Browney

You'll be four and a half atleast. :S

I reckon we'll be 3 and a half, maybe pushing four.

Jones - 80/1
Bent - 78
Cattermole - 76
Cana - 78
Malbranque and Richardson around 75
Da Silva - 74

---

I think four stars is right for us as only a few teams reach 5 stars, with all the other greatest teams in the world reaching four and a half stars, which isn't us just yet. :P Bent should be 80 IMO.

Couple of points...

• Console section, in the FIFA 10 thread
• We're five stars

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Browney

You'll be four and a half atleast. :S

I reckon we'll be 3 and a half, maybe pushing four.

Jones - 80/1
Bent - 78
Cattermole - 76
Cana - 78
Malbranque and Richardson around 75
Da Silva - 74

---

Catt will be higher than 76.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lBlue

Couple of points...

• Console section, in the FIFA 10 thread
• We're five stars

---

Ah well, the Mod's will probably move it then, but I want to see everyones views in this section, as I'm not sure if they even look at that section, because I don't and I didn't even think of posting it there to be honest as I only really use this section and a couple of others rarely.


Any link to prove we're five stars?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flamedragon3

Ah well, the Mod's will probably move it then, but I want to see everyones views in this section, as I'm not sure if they even look at that section, because I don't and I didn't even think of posting it there to be honest as I only really use this section and a couple of others rarely.


Any link to prove we're five stars?

---

Fair enough.

And when I added the players to our team and removed Elano etc we're five stars. All done via stats, the workers don't randomly decide what star they'll be. :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lBlue

Fair enough.

And when I added the players to our team and removed Elano etc we're five stars. All done via stats, the workers don't randomly decide what star they'll be. :P

---

I can't tell about FIFA 09 as my xbox broke. :/ So the closest I can see what are team may be like is FIFA 08, which isn't too great as Adebayour is only 78 with Bojinov on 79! lmao.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Andys

Catt will be higher than 76.

---

He was barely pushing 70 last season, don't reckon he'll be too high.

And maybe Bent should be 80...

Four stars?, How the hell will we go down half a star by bringing in some great players.

Crazy person.


CBA so i just copied n edited your list

GK
Given - 86
Taylor - 74
Hart - 71 (loan)

DEF
Richards - 75
Zabaleta - 72
Toure - 83
Dunne - 74
Lescott - 83 (if the deal is going to be completed lol YEH LOL)
Onouha - 72
Bridge - 78
Sylvinho - 73
Garrido - dno
Logan - 71 dnoBen-Haim - dno
CDM
Barry - 84
Kompany - 78

MID
De Jong - 81
Wright-Phillips - 81
Ireland - 79
Robinho - 86
Petrov - 75
Weiss - 75
Etuhu - dno
McDermott dnoJohnson - dno
ATK
Adebayour - 87
Tevez - 85
Santa Cruz - 81
Bellamy - 80
Caicedo - dno
Jo - dno
Bojinov - dno
Benjani - dno

Ireland won't be 79 and Adebayor(*) won't be 87.

Man City won't be four stars, lol.
They'll be 4 n half or 5.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

Four stars?, How the hell will we go down half a star by bringing in some great players.

Crazy person.


CBA so i just copied n edited your list

GK
Given - 86
Taylor - 74
Hart - 71 (loan)

DEF
Richards - 75
Zabaleta - 72
Toure - 83
Dunne - 74
Lescott - 83 (if the deal is going to be completed lol YEH LOL)
Onouha - 72
Bridge - 78
Sylvinho - 73
Garrido - dno
Logan - 71 dnoBen-Haim - dno
CDM
Barry - 84
Kompany - 78

MID
De Jong - 81
Wright-Phillips - 81
Ireland - 79
Robinho - 86
Petrov - 75
Weiss - 75
Etuhu - dno
McDermott dnoJohnson - dno
ATK
Adebayour - 87
Tevez - 85
Santa Cruz - 81
Bellamy - 80
Caicedo - dno
Jo - dno
Bojinov - dno
Benjani - dno

---

Well I didn't know our team was four and a half stars on FIFA 09? The last time I played it was back in February before we made the rest of the signings this summer, so I haven't done any updates for my team, and my xbox has been broken for over a month. The last I remember on that game was we were rated at four stars and Villa was rated at four and a half stars.

Ireland 79? Onouha 72? Zabaleta 72? :S Surely Ireland has at least a better overall rating than De Jong, Bellamy, Santa Cruz and SWP? :P

Crazy person :D lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flamedragon3

Well I didn't know our team was four and a half stars on FIFA 09? The last time I played it was back in February before we made the rest of the signings this summer, so I haven't done any updates for my team, and my xbox has been broken for over a month. The last I remember on that game was we were rated at four stars and Villa was rated at four and a half stars.

Ireland 79? Onouha 72? Zabaleta 72? :S Surely Ireland has at least a better overall rating than De Jong, Bellamy, Santa Cruz and SWP? :P

Crazy person :D lol

---

No no no shut face.

Ireland is rated **** on Fifa, i dont know why he should be like 85 but he wont be.

And Ade will be near that or could reach it oin adidas live season especially as hes doing wel at the moment.

cba soz. stoke are best tho init, rory delap gonna av his longthrowssssssss

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Browney

He was barely pushing 70 last season, don't reckon he'll be too high.

And maybe Bent should be 80...

---

He's a potential English international, already good enough to break into the squad ahead of Barry imo.
Should be quite abit higher than that.

Ireland will be rated about 82.
Adebayor about 84/85.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

No no no shut face.

Ireland is rated **** on Fifa, i dont know why he should be like 85 but he wont be.

And Ade will be near that or could reach it oin adidas live season especially as hes doing wel at the moment.

---

Trust me, Ireland won't be badly rated on FIFA... He's player of the season for us last season, he came close to winning young player of the year (which I think he should have done) last season.

FIFA only rated him badly as he doesn't play for Northern Ireland, so they probably presumed he wasn't good enough which isn't the case. They will look into it and know he isn't playing for Northern Ireland because of that problem he had a few years back.

Ireland in FIFA 10 will be one of the players who have really good detail on his looks.

And no I won't 'shut my face'. :rolleyes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flamedragon3

Trust me, Ireland won't be badly rated on FIFA... He's player of the season for us last season, he came close to winning young player of the year (which I think he should have done) last season.

FIFA only rated him badly as he doesn't play for Northern Ireland, so they probably presumed he wasn't good enough which isn't the case. They will look into it and know he isn't playing for Northern Ireland because of that problem he had a few years back.

Ireland in FIFA 10 will be one of the players who have really good detail on his looks.

And no I won't 'shut my face'. :rolleyes:

---

Trust me?

Haha you sound like you think you know anything

'Trust me' he wont be higher than 80.

I will lol when the game comes out and you're wrong AlexOC. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tristan

I will lol when the game comes out and you're wrong AlexOC. :)

---

And i will not care?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

Trust me?

Haha you sound like you think you know anything

'Trust me' he wont be higher than 80.

---

I'm not trying to sound like I know anything at all. :/ I'm just saying that he will be over 80. Don't have to act like a jerk to me about it because I'm saying our player will be over 80 on a game. Even a United fan is saying Ireland will be over 80!

Just go cry to Heart about the next HxF United update. :rolleyes:

OK.

Ireland will be over 80, please stop talking to me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

OK.

Ireland will be over 80, please stop talking to me.

---

Its a free country. I will speak if I please. Also, your the one replying to my comments. ;)

Gomes - 81

Bale - 79
King - 81
Bassong - 80
Assou Ekotto - 80

Lennon - 83
Jenas - 80
Modric - 83/84
Palacios - 80

Defoe - 83/84
Keane - 82/83

other players;
Huddlestone - 79/80
Crouch - 79
Pavyluchenko - 79
Corluka - 80

Almunia (GK) - 83
Fabianski (GK) - 73

Sagna (RB) - 84
Eboue (RB) - 79

Gallas (CB) - 83
Vermaelen (CB) - 85
Djourou (CB) -75
Silvestre (CB) - 76
Senderos (CB) - 77

Clichy (LB) - 84
Traore (LB) - 77

Rosicky (RW) - 86
Walcott (RW) - 82

Fabregas (CM) - 89
Denilson (CM) - 81
Song (CM) - 81
Diaby (CM) - 82
Ramsey (CM) - 76

Nasri (LW) - 86
Wilshere (LW) - 80

Arshavin (CF) - 87
V. Persie (CF) - 86
Eduardo (CF) - 84
Bendtner (CF) - 80

In my opinion that's what it will be for us. I missed out 6 players but there not major players. It depends though, if they do the ratings based on last season or start of this season. If its the 2nd, then they might even be higher.

I think we will be a 4 and a half star team :)

As for Man City people thinking 5 Stars... your crazy. Hardly any team are 5 Stars, maybe Barca and Madrid but that's about it. City will be 4 at least, probably 4 and a half.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Soy

Gomes - 81

Bale - 79
King - 81
Bassong - 80
Assou Ekotto - 80

Lennon - 83
Jenas - 80
Modric - 83/84
Palacios - 80

Defoe - 83/84
Keane - 82/83

other players;
Huddlestone - 79/80
Crouch - 79
Pavyluchenko - 79
Corluka - 80

---

Defoe should be pretty high, i think Keane might be a little lower though.

Keane should be around 82 maybe 81

yeah defoe has had a great start

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CHA!NGANG

As for Man City people thinking 5 Stars... your crazy. Hardly any team are 5 Stars, maybe Barca and Madrid but that's about it. City will be 4 at least, probably 4 and a half.

---

I think in FIFA 08, not one team was 5 stars lol. I can't remember about FIFA 09 though. Only United are 5 stars in that I think? :S

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CHA!NGANG

Almunia (GK) - 83
Fabianski (GK) - 73

Sagna (RB) - 84
Eboue (RB) - 79

Gallas (CB) - 83
Vermaelen (CB) - 85
Djourou (CB) -75
Silvestre (CB) - 76
Senderos (CB) - 77

Clichy (LB) - 84
Traore (LB) - 79

Rosicky (RW) - 86
Walcott (RW) - 82

Fabregas (CM) - 89 not that high, surely? 87 maybe, 88
Denilson (CM) - 81
Song (CM) - 81
Diaby (CM) - 82
Ramsey (CM) - 76

Nasri (LW) - 86
Wilshere (LW) - 80

Arshavin (CF) - 87
V. Persie (CF) - 86
Eduardo (CF) - 84
Bendtner (CF) - 80

---

bold is moi.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flamedragon3

I think in FIFA 08, not one team was 5 stars lol. I can't remember about FIFA 09 though. Only United are 5 stars in that I think? :S

---

LOTS of teams are 5star in Fifa 09

Barca
Liverpool (these are maybe 4 n half?)
Chelsea
Inter
Milan
Real
Bayern Munich
Juventus

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Browney

bold is moi.

---

Hmm.. Personally I think he should be 89, but he will probably be 87/88 so yeah your right. I'd also change Almunia to 82, Traore to 78 and Gallas to 84 now thinking about it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

LOTS of teams are 5star in Fifa 09

Barca
Liverpool
Chelsea
Inter
Milan
Real
Bayern Munich

---

And your saying Man City are on par with them? Your not even in the Champions League. You are unproven and definently not as good as those teams and until you are a Champions League team, and finish in the top 4 you won't be 5 Stars. You will be 4 and a half.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CHA!NGANG

Hmm.. Personally I think he should be 89, but he will probably be 87/88 so yeah your right. I'd also change Almunia to 82, Traore to 78 and Gallas to 84 now thinking about it.



And your saying Man City are on par with them? Your not even in the Champions League. You are unproven and definently not as good as those teams and until you are a Champions League team, and finish in the top 4 you won't be 5 Stars. You will be 4 and a half.

---

Its nothing about where you are in the tables, its based on the average player ratings, thats why when you make a dreamteam on a league 2 team they will go to 5 stars.

If people like robinho, tevez, adebayor and stuff are rated quite high then we could easily be 5 star.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

Its nothing about where you are in the tables, its based on the average player ratings, thats why when you make a dreamteam on a league 2 team they will go to 5 stars.

If people like robinho, tevez, adebayor and stuff are rated quite high then we could easily be 5 star.

---

5 Stars is all players on average 85 I think. You won't have that average. Also, I think it's also done on Team Chemistry or something like that but I might be wrong on that.

It's not done on Team Chemistry.
Likelihood is that Man City will be 5 stars.

Teams on 5 stars include:
Man Utd
Chelsea
Arsenal
Bayern Munich
Real Madrid
Barcelona
Inter
AC Milan
Juventus

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tristan

It's not done on Team Chemistry.
Likelihood is that Man City will be 5 stars.

Teams on 5 stars include:
Man Utd
Chelsea
Arsenal
Bayern Munich
Real Madrid
Barcelona
Inter
AC Milan
Juventus

---

What about Liverpool? And I still think they will be 4 and a half, but it depends on how they do it.

No, Liverpool are 4 1/2.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tristan

It's not done on Team Chemistry.
Likelihood is that Man City will be 5 stars.

Teams on 5 stars include:
Man Utd
Chelsea
Arsenal
Bayern Munich
Real Madrid
Barcelona
Inter
AC Milan
Juventus

---

You just copied my list!!

Also Arsenal are 4 1/2 with Adebayor and Toure gone.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tristan

No, Liverpool are 4 1/2.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexOC

You just copied my list!!

Also Arsenal are 4 1/2 with Adebayor and Toure gone.

---

Not really. Are you basing this all on Fifa 09? Seeing as alot of ratings of players change I doubt you can say anything for sure, except the obvious. I think Arsenal will be 4 and a half and same with Man City. Liverpool will be 5 in my opinion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CHA!NGANG

Not really. Are you basing this all on Fifa 09? Seeing as alot of ratings of players change I doubt you can say anything for sure, except the obvious. I think Arsenal will be 4 and a half and same with Man City. Liverpool will be 5 in my opinion.

---

Yeh Liverpool will be 5 stars no doubt.