Printable View
Argh, ok i have a rag step-dad (obviously not from manchester, from down south) but he keeps annoying me by saying Berbatov is better than anything city have got, and i just think is stupid, i mean he's not better than Ade, Robi or Tevez.
What do you think? No biased-nes so United fans dont just go 'Berbatov is better k.'
Berbatov is good, but Ive always preferred Tevez.
Though its quite hard to compare the two. There both good in their own ways.
didn't see much of robinho but i think ade and tevez are better than berbatov
He's deluded.
Whom is?Quote:
Originally Posted by lBlue
The rag, presumably.
Ade > Berba > Tevez > RobinhoQuote:
Originally Posted by AlexOC
Rated them on what they add to their respective teams. ;)
I don't know :/
Robi was our top scorer last year.
Yeah, but now you have Ade, and can play Robi on LW.
I suppose, i can see Ade being our Top score now anyway.
But berbatov?, 6 - 8 maybe?
Probably, but scoring aint his job. That's why I find some of the players you mentioned hard to compare.
I don't see Berba as a goal scorer.. I see him as a genius.
The berb > Ade > Tevez > Rob
Yeh i suppose, the impact they have on the club is more suitable, still i don't think berbatov scores high in that rating either.
Wheres good old ched these days
Doing well at his new club.
I rate Robinho and Ade higher than Berba but not Tevez. Robinho has raw talent and amazing skill which is why I rate him higher, Ade is a natural goal scorer wihch is what I rated him higher. Tevez is quite similar to Berba in terms of Assists, but I think Berba has that little bit on him, but give it a year or two and Tevez will be better than Berba. That's my opinion but as people have said, hard to compare them all.
I'd rather have Berba than any of the said three. Genuinely. Tevez scores just as much as Berba but doesn't set up half as many as Berba does. Adebayor has quality but he's an idiot in my opinion and I don't rate Robinho.
Yeh i get the impression he's a clown.
tevez is better than berba
robinho is better than berba
adebayor is CURRENTLY better than berba
berba is just a big lump with some good skill.
does that answer your question? :P
All of the players have skill and qualities about them.
For those who need some convincing; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rt63U66NOaY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQ4sB-PHlgkQuote:
Originally Posted by Excellent2
doesn't make him better than tevez, robinho, and whatnot.
berba is a genius
so is ebanks, watch the video i posted ~ but it doesn't make him better than any of the city strikers, so why should it apply for berbaflop?
because he contributed to a team who won the league, champs league final and fa cup semis. he played a pretty active part in that.
Didnt think man u got the the fa cup final :s
SEMIS.
he said he was gna "sweat blood" this year
how do u sweat blood
well he is a genius
I don't think my opinion on whose best would really be any good since I'm a City fan. But I think that if Berbatov was still playing for Spurs and played like he was there, only then could you rate him as good as any of City's main three strikers.
Oh any Browney, Robinho played LW last season and still mananged 15 goals. He probably won't get as many this season though as we actually have strikers capable of scoring often now.
Init, thats whar I meant.Quote:
Originally Posted by Flamedragon3
Great player out of his prime though now and shows on the pitch
should have joined spurs about 7 years ago, would have had a much more reputable career
CF Is a better position for him