I thought you were allowed to call people idiots, I'm sure it was somewhere in feedback before? Tara just called someone an idiot in a thread and got banned for it? :S
Printable View
I thought you were allowed to call people idiots, I'm sure it was somewhere in feedback before? Tara just called someone an idiot in a thread and got banned for it? :S
i thought the rule had changed too :o
i think ppl should be able to express their opinions about others, aslong as it doesnt get personal or racist then it should be ok
I thought it was
you could ask someone a question, for example:
Are you stupid hoteluser?
not
your stupid hoteluser
cos he could reply to the question with yes or no
Hmm I have to say that sounds more familiar. I don't believe we've ever simply allowed people to call each other idiots - it's still rude whichever way you look at it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Richie
It depends on the situation.
If it was used in a way which was deemed as targetting a forum member or in an offensive manner then it would be the moderators choice on how to deal with it?
I don't think she deserved an infraction, the most she should get is a PM/warning. Is there actually anything in the rules about calling people idiots?Quote:
Originally Posted by Jamesy
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skizzling
I think that covers it :)Quote:
A1. Respect other forum members ~ Always respect other forum members, this means do not be rude towards them and respect their opinions. You should not bully or victimise other members for any reason and you should not behave in a negative manner excessively.
*REMOVED*Quote:
Originally Posted by Skizzling
o/t yeh its harsh
Edited by Bolt660 (Forum Super Moderator): Please do not be rude to other forum members
I dont get it, if u dont want ppl being rude then why not just filter idiot since thats what management seem to be doing with anything midly offensive, coz lets be honest most ppl just use idiot as an insult.
or we could just do what i said above and not be so "OMG HE CALLED ME AN IDIOT :'( :'( :'(" about it
As far as I'm aware there has been no rule change, and calling someone an idiot is against the forum rules. It's singling someone out and targetting them in a negative way. It's completely uncalled for, will cause further arguments and it's a pleasant thing to be happening.
We have a PM, warning, infraction system in place and that has been followed here. The rules say "Respect other forum members". Calling them an idiot is not.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bolt660
but the person might actually be an idiot
Idiot is a Telugu film which released on 22 August 2002 and was directed by Puri Jagannadh. This film stars Ravi Teja and Rak****a. This film was a big hit in 2002.This film was a remake of the Superhit kannada movie Appu.
HOTELUSER YOU TELUGU FILM
dnt ban me :'(
Because it can be used non offensively. It's all down to context. The only words that are filtered are ones that are bad in all contexts. In regards to your last point, Martin has summed it up beautifully.Quote:
Originally Posted by NaughtyNemo
Quote:
Originally Posted by Richie
Enciting the argument/accusation is still causing the problem. You could say the same about the scamming/hacking rule. You may know they are so and so, but accusing them of this and name calling is going to cause upset and arguments which is unpleasant on the forum. It's the same in this case, and even starting the argument/targetting is seen as being rude.
If we allowed everyone to insult other forum members the forum would become a more negative place full of arguments and unprovoked attacks.
If you have a problem with a moderator or their decision, you can contact the relevant people, calling them an idiot in a thread certainly isn't going to help.
Well that's not entirely true, an example being the word bitch, there are other words too which can be used in a non offensive contextQuote:
Originally Posted by Jamesy
Calling someone an idiot is rude, no doubt about it. Rule A1:
Quote:
A1. Respect other forum members ~ Always respect other forum members, this means do not be rude towards them and respect their opinions. You should not bully or victimise other members for any reason and you should not behave in a negative manner excessively.
If people have a problem with someone else, let them. Let them get it out rather than this underlying negative atmosphere where people hate each other but cant express it so you just have sarcastic comments all over the shop. Also would help against banning some of the few really active people that we have left on this forum. Enough of this parent attitude where people aren't allowed to say what they want about a person. Sure if a thread turns into purely arguement, then close it. But if people can't say what they think about something (in this case a person) then can we really call this a forum?Quote:
Originally Posted by Bolt660
also what josh said
kallin sum1 an idiot is rude n against the habox way
enjoi ur ban oxoxo
It's not a "parent" attitude. It's not wanting the place filled with people being nasty and horrible to each other. If you want to go be immature and throw insults at each other like children then there are plenty of other places and mediums in which to do it. The people who are banned are the ones who keep breaking the rules - it's as simple as that. This is a pretty non-issue here, a user broke the rules and got infracted for it. There's no excuse and no argument, if you have a complaint about a moderators actions there is a relevant forum.Quote:
Originally Posted by NaughtyNemo
Thread Closed