Dannii Minogue

[Alkaz]

I really think that over the past three series we've really seen her come into her own. The first series I know there was problems between her and Sharon but I think in her second season she became more her self and the series just gone I thought she was brilliant and how she handled the thing with Jedward and how she knew that she lost two act's to them etc. She just seemed so much more grown up, dignified and almost everything she said made sense and was constructive to each contestant.

I really hope that next year (after this year) she makes a return to the X Factor or TV because I really like her now and it would be a shame to loose her so soon. Thoughts on her and X Factor?

[Black_Apalachi]

Even though this isn't saying much, she's the best judge on the show.

[kk.]

Best judge.

She leaving?

[Alkaz]

Yeah she is preg and her baby is due around the same time as the initial filming of the auditions are taking place and she said she is going to australia to have her baby etc so it wouldn't be fair for her or her baby and just wouldn't really work with a new born baby so ye she isn't doing it this year/again.

[kk.]

Ahh yh, I remember now

damn, she really was the best judge. Hope they don't do the guest judge thing. Bring sharon back for a series!!

[Alkaz]

I doubt she would do it because she would know she was ''replacing'' Dannii and she hates her lmao. I hope Amanda Holden DOESN'T get the job but someone like er.. someone else gets the job or they keep it as three judges because I think the whole format is changing and I'm not sure if they going to have groups anymore, more like American Idol but ye.

[kk.]

They wouldn't do it like AI, I thought Simon disliked that format.
I remember they may possibly have 1 from every group, so 1 boy, 1 girl, a group, and 1 25+ which would be cool

[Black_Apalachi]

They better change it a lot because as it stands I'm not watching it any more anyway. If it was different though it might regain my interest...

[Alex3213]

I doubt she would do it because she would know she was ''replacing'' Dannii and she hates her lmao. I hope Amanda Holden DOESN'T get the job but someone like er.. someone else gets the job or they keep it as three judges because I think the whole format is changing and I'm not sure if they going to have groups anymore, more like American Idol but ye.

I prefered it as 3 judges, it made it seem more sensible due to being a small, odd number. Shame she's leaving because she was certainly very good and I hope she makes a return the year after.

[kk.]

Pay least having 3 judges meant that it was almost impossible to go to deadlock unless someone refused to vote