Did you cry when you watch Titanic?

[hindu]

Titanic is a comedy from my perspective...

"///////

[womanizer]

No

..........

[Twinkie]

No, I didn't. I actually thought the film was quite cheesy. I can't comprehend how that film made a lot of money.

[Mentor]

In the sense that the film wasn't a comedy, and clearly wasn't meant to be. Whether it was a bad portrayal of the events that happened it still is none-the-less not a comedy and blatently isn't meant to be. If in your opinion it sucked, it still doesn't make it a comedy and pretty much everyone with a few brain cells here and there know it's not...

And everyone else here with more than your few brain cells, knows that it doesnt need to aim to be funny, to turn out funny in the end. The pure rediculsness and cheesyness of situations did all that for them. The Blaintent disregaud for any use of reality or realsim within the film, the melodramtic theming?

The complety unrealistic and VERY dergoative actions taken by the shipos crew, most of which Died trying to save the passengers, and didnt take any seats in lifeboats, other than the few crew needed to guide them. Yet in the film there sitting there locking people down below to drown.... Yet you dont find that offencive in anyway??

[English]

And everyone else here with more than your few brain cells, knows that it doesnt need to aim to be funny, to turn out funny in the end. The pure rediculsness and cheesyness of situations did all that for them. The Blaintent disregaud for any use of reality or realsim within the film, the melodramtic theming?

The complety unrealistic and VERY dergoative actions taken by the shipos crew, most of which Died trying to save the passengers, and didnt take any seats in lifeboats, other than the few crew needed to guide them. Yet in the film there sitting there locking people down below to drown.... Yet you dont find that offencive in anyway??

More than my few brain cells? That appears to be a poor comeback which didn't really acheive anything "/ It didn't aim to be funny and didn't appear to be funny, like 95% of people who have seen the film can tell you that. Ofcourse there's the minority of losers/disrespectful/and other people who just laughed for no reason "/ That blatent disregard for realism in the film? Hello what's not so real about situations portrayed on the Titanic? Can you tell me what exactly would happen based on that situation?
I bet plenty of crew-members would rather die saving passengers than stay alive/even die a selfish man. However there are alot of selfish people in this world who only think of themselves. Just because they locked people down below to drown doesnt make the situation of people dying any less and laughing at it.

[Mentor]

More than my few brain cells? That appears to be a poor comeback which didn't really acheive anything "/ It didn't aim to be funny and didn't appear to be funny, like 95% of people who have seen the film can tell you that.

Someone slipping on a banana peal (unless there a clown) doesnt aim to be funny, doesnt change whether it actualy is or not.

Of course there's the minority of losers/disrespectful/and other people who just laughed for no reason "/ That blatent disregard for realism in the film?

Realism? what film were you watching?

Hello what's not so real about situations portrayed on the Titanic? Can you tell me what exactly would happen based on that situation?

Well unlike the film, the titanic didnt actualy have a double hull, and its bulkheads were only 3 meters above the water level, (aka they were not water tight as they are today) So there was no bursting threw of bulkheads, water simply overflowed them.
The titanic had no real warning sytsem, so many people were unaware the ship was sinking, and most the panicing never happened. In the day men were obligiated to let the women and children bored the life boats, and sacrifve themselves (not shown in the film) The crew also went down with the ship, insted of locking people below to drown, while in reality they all sacrived the lifes to save them. Yet you call people who laugh at the film disrespectful, not the people who portray people who sacrivsed there lifes as murders?

Interesting morality there.

The Classic steriotypical hollywood relationship, and the behavoral trends did not fit with the time period in the slighest, and are things that simply would not have happeed in the socal contexted, The class devide was pretty much ignored, even futuramas parody did a better job of exspressing this than the titanic film.

I bet plenty of crew-members would rather die saving passengers than stay alive/even die a selfish man. However there are alot of selfish people in this world who only think of themselves. Just because they locked people down below to drown doesnt make the situation of people dying any less and laughing at it.

SO you dont think portraying people who sacrivided there lifes as murders is disrespectful?
So if someone makes a 9/11 film where the firemen and police are locking people in the building you wouldnt find that at all disrepectful ether? Since thats exsacty what happening in this film isnt it?
Yet youd be fully in support of it o.0

Becuse thats what youve just been saying. So i would really suggest you dont attempt to use a " being respectful" defence in context with the truely appualing film.