Christina @ VMA'S! WATCH!

[Susie Dent]

I doubt even Mariah Carey could hold a note whilst dancing so much.

Ew, look at the size of her, of course she couldn't. All she can do is make fanny fart noises.

[Eamonn]

Christina is an AMAZING live performer so it was a little disappointing for her to lip sync but I didn't know she went live again at the end of the performance so fair do's to her - I doubt even Mariah Carey could hold a note whilst dancing so much.

I'm hooked on the new song though and the remix of GIAB had a really funky tune in the background

Mariah doesn't dance, well not greatly anyway, the most she has really done is in 'Honey' and 'Heartbreaker' which isn't much.

Anyways CHRISTINA = BOW
Gaga = Who? ol:

LOL please, Gaga is good in her own right, but she has nothing on Xtina, vocally, sexually, performance wise, lyrically, practically everything.

Xtina > The rest

& LFR, people moaning about Xtina lip syncing, Britney is one of the biggest lip syncers in the business and no one complains, doesn't mean she is crap either

It's a situation where Christina isn't going to win, people would have complained if she just stood there and sang this song and people have complained, even whilst she owned it with her AMAZING dance moves but lip synced.

[Hate]

um didnt christina say it was dumb and unprofessional to lip sync a "live" performance

[gaga1]

Mariah doesn't dance, well not greatly anyway, the most she has really done is in 'Honey' and 'Heartbreaker' which isn't much.

Anyways CHRISTINA = BOW
Gaga = Who? ol:

LOL please, Gaga is good in her own right, but she has nothing on Xtina, vocally, sexually, performance wise, lyrically, practically everything.

Xtina > The rest

& LFR, people moaning about Xtina lip syncing, Britney is one of the biggest lip syncers in the business and no one complains, doesn't mean she is crap either

It's a situation where Christina isn't going to win, people would have complained if she just stood there and sang this song and people have complained, even whilst she owned it with her AMAZING dance moves but lip synced.

Eamonn how DARE you.

She has plenty on Christina. Christina isn't as innovative as she once was, Lady GaGa is one of the most innovative artists around right now. Gaga's performances are great and she even sings live, all while dancing frantically.

The thing about the lip syncing, Britney doesn't go around saying "its dumb and unprofessional to mime a live performance", Christina did and now she's going to have to eat her own words. Appearance wise, Christina did rip Lady Gaga off and nobody can disagree with that because the similiarities are endless.

I'm a fan of Xtina but that took the piss. I'm surprised Britney wasn't sat in the crowd saying "Hey, why is Lady Gaga on the stage lip syncing and wearing my Onyx tour catsuit?"

[Invent]

How the hell is she one of the most innovative artists?

[gaga1]

"Lady GaGa is one of the most innovative artists around right now."

You're a fan of Elliot Minor, you wouldn't understand.

[Invent]

Fantastic argument, compare a woman who knows how to just play the piano with a group of guys who are clasically trained in piano, violin, double bass, chello and many other instruments. But ya, Elliot Minor are far more unique in terms of music as well as vocals than this gaga woman .

[gaga1]

Fantastic argument, compare a woman who knows how to just play the piano with a group of guys who are clasically trained in piano, violin, double bass, chello and many other instruments. But ya, Elliot Minor are far more unique in terms of music as well as vocals than this gaga woman .

A woman who's still more talented than all band members put together. Her creativity surpasses Elliott Minor's and her music doesn't sound studio enhanced, theirs do. You don't need to argue the fact that EM are better because it's not going to go anywhere; it's fact that they're under Lady Gaga as far as vocal talent, fantastic performances and in terms of being innovative. Lady GaGa has a mature audience, not a crowd of wannabe scene people jumping around to your preference of music that will make your ears bleed.

And to the Piano comment, she learned it at age 4, wrote her first piano ballad at 13 and was given a placement in TSA aged 17.

[stickwitu]

lady gaga is one of the only musicians right now actually doing something different in pop, and yeah maybe christina was inspired from villians etc. but she still looked like gaga, and the sound is still very similar (apart from the fact that the track fails in comparison to a majority of The Fame).

i dont mind christina copying or following other artists directions, but she needs to do her own thing. B2B was a good album, and had they turned it into a 1 disc album i reckon people would rate it a lot higher and it was individual, but with each album she changes completely and it doesn't make her a reliable artist because you can't guarantee you'll like what she does next.

i dont like this direction. it's not unique. and if this track is a sign for things to come then i'm not impressed. i would prefer her doing pop/rock tracks like on stripped. it worked sales-wise, and it got praise.