Not if you go back to the original post its not, its to do with the actual creation of the universe not how it became to be formed as we know it. There is no actual scientific dispute on how it came to be formed as we know it now, the universe used to be in an area the size of a baseball and has expanded from there.
But the question is directly to do with how the universe came into exitence. All im saying is that saying "God" explains nothing. And if god can exist forever then so could the universe, or the two original protons. Thus if you argue that everything has to be created then you can't simply decide to end that rule when you wish to invoke god.














