Most Over/Under Rated player in England.

[Loser]

Too many choices for overrated, but for underrated, I'll go with Michael Carrick.

[Bun]

Who over rates Nani?

Most United fans think he is rubbish..

Edited by preposterous (Forum Moderator) - Please don't double post.

maybe fans of other teams?



over: nani
under: johnson (when he gets his game) :eusa_wall

[Skajo]

The price Funguson paid for Nani suggests how highly he rated him...

[leah]

Over - Ronaldo *step over, dives, cries*
Under - Carragher - he's really dedicated, hard working and a great defender but no one really mentions him.

[Twist]

Under: Ashley young
Over: Federico macheda

Reason for above;
He's only had 2 games at top flight level. Even though I'm a United fan I think everyone has jumped on the band wagon too soon.

Have you even seen him play? Or did you just read the papers and automatically assume he is crap :S?

Under- Carrick
Over- Carragher, Reina, Gerrard

Lol idiot.

Edited by preposterous (Forum Moderator) - Please don't insult other members.

[sock]

actually in fact i'll add to my list..

Under - Jason Scotland, Michael Carrick, Luka Modric

Over - Dimitar Berbatov, Anderson, Reina, Paul Robinson

[Twist]

actually in fact i'll add to my list..

Under - Jason Scotland, Michael Carrick, Luka Modric

Over - Dimitar Berbatov, Anderson, Reina, Paul Robinson

Didn't realise anyone actually rated Robinson anymore .
Is he Blackburn's number 1 still? Haven't heard his name mentioned in time.

[sock]

ye he is but he's a pile of crapp

[Jack.Lfc]

Over: Anderson, Ferdinand (watch him when vidic is injured, he's all over the place, vidic carries him)
Under: Tim Cahill

[JackBuddy]

Over: Any United youngster. Richard Eckersley is soooo good.
Under: Benayoun, Matty Taylor.