Defoe or Tevez?

[AlexOC]

I disagree.

Tevez should get more goals, assists and minutes

[Geraint]

Defoe. Tevez will have more assists but Defoe also chips him with a few himself. Also, with Tevez, he might not start every game with the team that Man City have, saying that, Spurs have 4 themselves but I'd go for Defoe.

[Flamedragon3]

Its hard to choose, but I would probably choose Tevez, and I'm not only choosing him because he plays for City. When he was playing for United, ever time he had a chance on the pitch, he played his heart out and really made big impacts in their games. Now that he's with City, he can shine more as long as he gets to play every game (which he should be doing), and with the quality of Rooney and Ronaldo not in our team, then he has more chances to get some goals himself, with players like Ireland and Robinho who can set him up with many chances at goal.

[lBlue]

What do you want?

• Assists
• 6/10 goals a season
• Appearances
• Match wins

• 10/13 goals a season
• Appearances

[Browney]

Its hard to choose, but I would probably choose Tevez, and I'm not only choosing him because he plays for City. When he was playing for United, ever time he had a chance on the pitch, he played his heart out and really made big impacts in their games. Now that he's with City, he can shine more as long as he gets to play every game (which he should be doing), and with the quality of Rooney and Ronaldo not in our team, then he has more chances to get some goals himself, with players like Ireland and Robinho who can set him up with many chances at goal.

I can see it now.

90 minutes played | 2
Bonus | 3
Working his bonny little heart out | 4

And Matty, you think Tevez could 10 goals? :S He never got that many for the best club in England, why do you think he'll do it on the other side of the city?

[lBlue]

I can see it now.

90 minutes played | 2
Bonus | 3
Working his bonny little heart out | 4

And Matty, you think Tevez could 10 goals? :S He never got that many for the best club in England, why do you think he'll do it on the other side of the city?

Because he's playing week in week out for 75+ minutes.

You're not going to judge him by coming onto the pitch for 15 minutes for about ten games are you?

[StefanWolves]

Because he's playing week in week out for 75+ minutes.

You're not going to judge him by coming onto the pitch for 15 minutes for about ten games are you?

I know what you're saying, more goals get more points... and I think Defoe will score more goals, but will get less assits than Tevez will.

Hard call, I got two weeks to wait anyway, but I'm definately bringing in one of these two.

[Browney]

Tevez isn't a goalscorer. He barely set up many goals either. You might as well put Fletcher upfront.

[StefanWolves]

Tevez isn't a goalscorer. He barely set up many goals either. You might as well put Fletcher upfront.

I'll bare that in mind, I'm actually contemplaiting bringing Darren Bent in instead.

[Browney]

No, Tevez or Defoe would both be better options than Bent.