Empire State Of Mind I or II?

[Sharon]

Jay Z & Alicia Keys - Empire State Of Mind
OR
Alicia Kays - Empire State Of Mine Part II?

Both really good I think but I'm starting to like Part II better

[Smits]

I prefer part one, but the second is still great.

[Adamm]

I prefer the first because I'm not too fond of Alicia Keys' cigarette-ruined rusty voice.

[Meree.]

Part 2 is way better.

[Cheryl]

IMO part I is wayy better than part II, as Adam said above Alisha Keys has a rusty voice :S But I do like her contribution to part I

[Black_Apalachi]

I think I prefer this. Just makes her seem more talented I guess, which is the only thing that makes me like pop music really

[Kipp]

I prefer the first one. Part 1

[clueless]

i like both a lot but probably 1

[dirrty]

i prefer part 1. part 2 is good though nevertheless.

[today]

part 2 sucks. so 1 for me