As a fan of the book, I'd say the movie was pretty good. I just saw it today.
A LOT of the symbolism and themes in the book were far too in-your-face for my liking (e.g. the green light, the eyes of Dr TJ Eckleburg), whereas I thought they were so effective in the novel because of the subtlety in contrast with the complete decadence of everything Jay Gatsby, which was spot on in the film. The party scenes were just ABSURDLY extravagant which is totally the point.
I think Jay Z did a great job with the soundtrack as well, Baz Luhrmann made a good decision to include modern music. I was a little sceptical about it but it is actually really effective within the context of the film and many of the songs (and others that aren't on the album) are remixed to give it that Jazz Age touch which really works well.
It was very good, wasn't blown away by it though. To me it just felt like Baz Luhrmann was overly conscious of getting across that he understood what Fitzgerald was doing with the novel, which almost made it come across as though he was trying to teach the audience about the themes and metaphors instead of actually using them in the way they were intended. He was needlessly explicit about these things.
But I'd definitely go and see it, whether you have read the book or not. It is stunning visually too.






Reply With Quote

) so I didn't know what to expect, and I thought it was great. My girlfriend had read the book, so like you guys she had a few issues with it, but for me, I thought it was brilliant 





