Is comitting suicide a selfish act?

[AgnesIO]

so u should probably refrain from commenting especially with something as trivial as train delays :S

Why shouldn't I comment? This is a fairly widely held view, particularly among commuters.

Selfish; "lacking consideration for other people".

Therefore, yes, technically it is a selfish act. And let's move on to the train driver; why should they have to suffer? Should they have to endure some muppet jumping in front of a train, potentially leaving that train driver scarred for life? Or does their life not matter?

[Yawn]

Why shouldn't I comment? This is a fairly widely held view, particularly among commuters.

Selfish; "lacking consideration for other people".

Therefore, yes, technically it is a selfish act. And let's move on to the train driver; why should they have to suffer? Should they have to endure some muppet jumping in front of a train, potentially leaving that train driver scarred for life? Or does their life not matter?

cos its a totally bizarre thing to say and rly insensitive and ur a terrible person for saying this :S

[AgnesIO]

cos its a totally bizarre thing to say and rly insensitive and ur a terrible person for saying this :S

Most expected -rep in the world.

Sorry, but this is an opinion I hold - and if you noticed the title of the debate it says "Is committing suicide a selfish act" - and in my view, yes, it is. Not just because of the train view - however that does build my opinion.

- - - Updated - - -

@lemons at least have the guts to reply and state why this post is disgusting...

Why shouldn't I comment? This is a fairly widely held view, particularly among commuters.

Selfish; "lacking consideration for other people".

Therefore, yes, technically it is a selfish act. And let's move on to the train driver; why should they have to suffer? Should they have to endure some muppet jumping in front of a train, potentially leaving that train driver scarred for life? Or does their life not matter?

Is it the muppet bit? If so, I thought I might annoy some overly sensitive people, but personally I do think it is a cruel, selfish act when thinking of the train driver - answer my question, why should they have to suffer as a result of someone they have NEVER done any harm to, are NOT to blame for the suicidal persons feelings and are NOT even connected to this person who jumps in front of a train?

I wish these people didn't jump, I wish their lives didn't reach a stage where they think they need to kill themselves; but please, don't jump in front of a train - lets ignore the commuters and tens of thousands of people who often have to wait all evening, but the train driver.

[Yawn]

Most expected -rep in the world.

Sorry, but this is an opinion I hold - and if you noticed the title of the debate it says "Is committing suicide a selfish act" - and in my view, yes, it is. Not just because of the train view - however that does build my opinion.

- - - Updated - - -

@lemons at least have the guts to reply and state why this post is disgusting...



Is it the muppet bit? If so, I thought I might annoy some overly sensitive people, but personally I do think it is a cruel, selfish act when thinking of the train driver - answer my question, why should they have to suffer as a result of someone they have NEVER done any harm to, are NOT to blame for the suicidal persons feelings and are NOT even connected to this person who jumps in front of a train?

I wish these people didn't jump, I wish their lives didn't reach a stage where they think they need to kill themselves; but please, don't jump in front of a train - lets ignore the commuters and tens of thousands of people who often have to wait all evening, but the train driver.

u didnt even initially mention the train driver so lets not try and flip this from ur original stupid point about delays and then standing in the rain lol. calling the suicide person a muppet was pretty shocking as well. u r a terrible person and im not interested in anything else u have to say, bye!

- - - Updated - - -

tbh ur entire 1st post was pretty stupid start to finish

[AgnesIO]

u didnt even initially mention the train driver so lets not try and flip this from ur original stupid point about delays and then standing in the rain lol. calling the suicide person a muppet was pretty shocking as well. u r a terrible person and im not interested in anything else u have to say, bye!

- - - Updated - - -

tbh ur entire 1st post was pretty stupid start to finish

Come off it, the post you -repped me for was about the driver. Get real, don't -rep a post and then say that "I -repped you for a different post" (as you effectively just have). I'm rly gld u fink im a terrible person, to be honest I'll take that with a pinch of salt. I've lost two close friends to illness, and to be honest, they would have done anything in their power to live; so yes, I think it is ******* selfish to kill yourself - I'm not going to pretend differently for the sake of some people that can't handle the other side of the debate, I don't really care if that view gets me -repped - it's a view that I hold, and one side of the two-sided debate!

But yeah, if my original post bothered you so much, why didn't you -rep that - instead you disliked the post that featured the train driver - so I'm not "flipping the coin" at all.

[Yawn]

Come off it, the post you -repped me for was about the driver. Get real, don't -rep a post and then say that "I -repped you for a different post" (as you effectively just have). I'm rly gld u fink im a terrible person, to be honest I'll take that with a pinch of salt. I've lost two close friends to illness, and to be honest, they would have done anything in their power to live; so yes, I think it is ******* selfish to kill yourself - I'm not going to pretend differently for the sake of some people that can't handle the other side of the debate, I don't really care if that view gets me -repped - it's a view that I hold, and one side of the two-sided debate!

But yeah, if my original post bothered you so much, why didn't you -rep that - instead you disliked the post that featured the train driver - so I'm not "flipping the coin" at all.

i -rep u for "muppet" but it was a general -rep u noob not that it matters or makes any difference to anything :S

some1 shouldnt have to continue and live a sad life because ur mate died of illness wtf everry1s life is different. ur doing my head in stop quoting me ur speaking absolute trash constantly ur evil

[AgnesIO]

i -rep u for "muppet" but it was a general -rep u noob not that it matters or makes any difference to anything :S

some1 shouldnt have to continue and live a sad life because ur mate died of illness wtf everry1s life is different. ur doing my head in stop quoting me ur speaking absolute trash constantly ur evil

I'm evil and terrible. Fantastic!

No, I am pointing out that for me killing yourself is wrong, when so many people don't even get the choice. Therefore, I consider suicide a selfish act; and part of my viewpoint is the thing about trains Nobody is forcing you to respond, either.

The original post that started this debate brought up the thing about trains; and the post also points out that it is a big debate.

[Yawn]

I'm evil and terrible. Fantastic!

No, I am pointing out that for me killing yourself is wrong, when so many people don't even get the choice. Therefore, I consider suicide a selfish act; and part of my viewpoint is the thing about trains Nobody is forcing you to respond, either.

The original post that started this debate brought up the thing about trains; and the post also points out that it is a big debate.

well they r all ******* moronic points, good day!

[AgnesIO]

well they r all ******* moronic points, good day!

What an intelligent response, although I expect nothing less. The point in a debate is just that; to debate (ie. argue the different sides). My side is one of the two key arguments; the fact you don't understand what a debate is simply isn't my problem.

[Yawn]

What an intelligent response, although I expect nothing less. The point in a debate is just that; to debate (ie. argue the different sides). My side is one of the two key arguments; the fact you don't understand what a debate is simply isn't my problem.

i have no interest in debating with u, *REMOVED*

i established tht in my 1st post but u kept saying more stupid/sick stuff sooooo this has nothing to do with my intelligence but im most likely smarter than u anyway

Edited by Matts (Forum Super Moderator): Please don't be rude to others.