Manchester derby

[Browney]

Valencia still has something to prove, but he's got a lot to offer.

@Minstrels; I don't rate Carrick at all, but I'd say he's on par with Ireland, and yes, they ARE smiliar players, as are Scholes and De Jong now (because Scholes doesn't charge forward as much anymore), Scholes can't tackle to save his life, but his passing more than makes up for that.

Scholes is there to rough teams up.

Anyway, in my opinion...

Rooney > Adebayor (1-0)
Berbatov > Tevez (2-0)
SWP > Valencia (2-1)
Ireland > Anderson (2-2)
Carrick > Barry (3-2)
Robinho > Nani (3-3)
Richards > O'Shea (3-4)
Vidic > Lescott (4-4)
Ferdinand > Toure (5-4)
Evra > Bridge (6-4)
Given > VDS (6-5)

Close but United's defence is much superior, City has a better Keeper, better wingers, better attacking mid in Ireland, but I'd still prefer Rooney to Adebayor, but Ade to Berba so it depends on your comparisons.

[Immenseman]

should be a good game anyway

[lBlue]

First team shirt.




Training top.

[Immenseman]

[lBlue]

[adaym]

GK

RB
CB
CB
LB

RM
CM
CM
LM

CF
CF

[Immenseman]

i'd rather have o'shea/brown at right back than richards.

[CHA!NGANG]

GK

RB
CB
CB
LB

RM
CM
CM
LM

CF
CF

I'm not sure which United midfielder your saying is better but I agree, except I think Barry is better than Carrick, but Hargreaves is better than De Jong. Also keeper wise... they are both top keepers and equal I'd say really but VDS might be a little bit better.

[Immenseman]

I think Given was by far Citys best buy.

[adaym]

Richards was a dodgy one but I still believe he's better than any crap United offer. Truly is your weakest area.

I agree Jake, Given is brilliant but VDS is better - for this season at least.

Carrick & Ireland in CM