HP: Deathly Hallows.

[Nemo]

Didn't even find that sad

Show Hide

I found dobby's and hedwig's death more upsetting than mad-eyes...

Same, they didnt even mention it after wtf ;l

[Hiro]

It was okay. I'm hoping Part 2 will be better, if they actually do a good job of the battle.

Part 1 had a decent start, then got pretty boring for 90 minutes, and then got better. Loved the cliffhanger though, great way to end it.

[Felix]

Wow it was great. How funny was it when Harry and jinny are kissing and Fred comes in quietly and just looks and says something ahahahajaha

[Neversoft]

I thought Harry's reaction to

Show Hide

Hedwig's death was quite good. It is difficult to explain his tone, but it was very desperate, mixed with surprise, guilt and of course sadness. I thought Daniel Radcliffe did a great job there, but I wish they would have actually addressed the owls death a couple of minutes later when the characters were out of trouble. Harry seemed to get over it way too fast.

One other thing that concerned me was

Show Hide

Umbridge's return. She was taken away by centaurs like two movies ago and I remember reading that she was saved by Dumbledore in the books (or something like that) but unless I am missing something from the film before this one, they never really showed what happened after she got taken away. They probably showed it in a short newspaper clipping in The Half Blood Prince or something, but I think they needed to explain what happened to her a little more as I was a little confused after she showed up in The Deathly Hallows.

It doesn't really leave you on a cliffhanger.

lolwut? Yes it does. :S

[MrPinkPanther]

Caution. Don't read if you haven't read the books!

I loved it especially when

Show Hide

we found out Harry is a Wizard

[ben]

Caution. Don't read if you haven't read the books!

I loved it especially when

Show Hide

we found out Harry is a Wizard

This is deathly hallows not the philosopher's stone. cy@~~~

[Mathew]

Just been to see this tonight. Absolutely brilliant film; as expected.

Show Hide

I think a bigger deal should have been made over the death of Hedwig and Mad-Eye but I do think the Dobby ordeal was very good (although sad! ).

There was a show on TV a couple of days ago showing you how they made some of the scenes which was a good watch if you missed it. Can't wait for the next one now!

[Judas]

i saw it last weekend and LOVEEEED IT. cannot wait for july now...

I thought Harry's reaction to

Show Hide

Hedwig's death was quite good. It is difficult to explain his tone, but it was very desperate, mixed with surprise, guilt and of course sadness. I thought Daniel Radcliffe did a great job there, but I wish they would have actually addressed the owls death a couple of minutes later when the characters were out of trouble. Harry seemed to get over it way too fast.

One other thing that concerned me was

Show Hide

Umbridge's return. She was taken away by centaurs like two movies ago and I remember reading that she was saved by Dumbledore in the books (or something like that) but unless I am missing something from the film before this one, they never really showed what happened after she got taken away. They probably showed it in a short newspaper clipping in The Half Blood Prince or something, but I think they needed to explain what happened to her a little more as I was a little confused after she showed up in The Deathly Hallows.

i completely agree with all of that

Show Hide

mad eye had a more important role and was probably a bigger loss than dobby (even if he did save them in his last moments but you know) so the lack of reaction to that, for me was a bit :S

[jackass]

I saw it last night, and quite simply, I thought it was incredible. Compared to the last film, they have barely removed or altered anything (main storyline-wise anyway) and the acting has got considerably better.

Just a shame about Mad-Eye's death being somewhat dismissed very quickly.

Also, in pretty much every scene, it's exactly how I imagined it when reading the book. Excellent work!

(Also also, I think i'm in love with Hermione).

[Con]

I saw it last night, and quite simply, I thought it was incredible. Compared to the last film, they have barely removed or altered anything (main storyline-wise anyway) and the acting has got considerably better.

Just a shame about Mad-Eye's death being somewhat dismissed very quickly.

Also, in pretty much every scene, it's exactly how I imagined it when reading the book. Excellent work!

(Also also, I think i'm in love with Hermione).

Couldn't agree any more!
I was a bit let down with the fight at the start (whilst transporting Harry to the burrow) because there's so much more they could have done, like falling off the bike.
Also when they were at Godrics Hollow - Voldemort didn't even come ;l

But thinking about it they made all the scenes very true to the book