Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2

[Neversoft]

Show Hide

neville ends up with hannah abbott + luna ends up with some random. y even put neville and luna at the end if that was the case

Show Hide

Yeah, that's one thing that irked me. The film seemed to hint at a romance between Neville and Luna but nothing of the sort had been explored or hinted previously so it seemed a bit spontaneous and pointless.

[dbgtz]

Show Hide

he was in love with Harry's mum Lily, they were friends when they were younger and during hogwarts and he was bullied by harry's dad James (even though he saved his life once) and Sirius etc. then he got in to a bad crowd and called Lily a mudblood so she broke off their friendship when they were around 15 years old. Snape hated Harry's dad and thought they were alike but he had her eyes. Snape was a death eater and he overheard a prophecy (the reason voldemort went for harry) but didn't listen to it all and he told voldemort about it, then voldemort decided to go for Harry and Snape asked him to spare Lily's life and he also asked Dumbledore to protect her but voldemort killed her anyway and so ever since he's been on Dumbledore's side, saving Harry because it's Lily's son. so ye it's really sad that he'd do all that for a woman n if you remember in part 1 there was a doe patronus that led Harry to the pond to get the sword of gryfindor, it was Snape's patronus which is also the same as Lily's that lead him there, so he put it there for him and was always really on Harry's side.

Show Hide

So was he never a bad guy or only a bad guy for a while?

[Slowpoke]

Show Hide

So was he never a bad guy or only a bad guy for a while?

Show Hide

Never a bad guy

[Inseriousity.]

I actually think the

Show Hide

Neville+Luna

should have been a canon relationship in the books. they seem to fit quite well together although mainly pre-DH.

I enjoyed it, I'd read some bad things about the

Show Hide

19 years later

bit so I was expecting to laugh but I think it worked much better in the films than it did in the books.

I didn't mind the changes tbh. Yeah sure...

Show Hide

Harry didn't say to Neville "Kill the snake" but regardless of that, the snake was just about to attack two of his friends - Ron and Hermione - and he happened to have the sword, you're not gonna say "OH WAIT HARRY TOLD ME NOT TO KILL IT SO I'LL JUST WATCH" In fact the only change I'm particularly bothered about is when Dumbledore says:

"I'd like to change the wording. Help will always be given to those who deserve it" NO NO NO dumbledore, it was perfect as it was. youve ruined the message of it now.

[Neversoft]

I actually think the

Show Hide

Neville+Luna

should have been a canon relationship in the books. they seem to fit quite well together although mainly pre-DH.

Show Hide

Nonono! Do not like the idea of Neville and Luna at all.

[Slowpoke]

Show Hide

Nonono! Do not like the idea of Neville and Luna at all.

Agreed!

[buttons]

Show Hide

So was he never a bad guy or only a bad guy for a while?

Show Hide

only before Lily died, he was a death eater from after hogwarts onwards so like 18-21 because remember he was in the same year as Harrys mum and dad and they died when they were 21 (Harrys dad looks well older lol) once she died he acted as voldemorts servant but was really dumbledores after voldemort killed Lily. If you think about it he saved Harrys life a lot like in the first one when he stopped quirell throwing Harry off his broom etc n even made potions to keep lupin from turning into a werewolf even though he didn't like him so yeah he was mostly a good guy, only person I recall him killing was dumbledore for good reason

oh and Chris only hates the

Show Hide

Luna and Neville because Luna's his fave

oh and another thing I wish they included was

Show Hide

where Harry figures out that what dumbledore sees in the mirror of erised and when he drank the potion in HBP but they didn't talk about Ariana so I guess they couldn't

[Slowpoke]

Show Hide

Snape changed sides BEFORE Lily was killed Jen

[buttons]

Show Hide

he changed as soon as he found he was going to kill lily as well as Harry, snape was the one who told voldemort about the prophecy in the first place so couldn't have been long in between the two

[Slowpoke]

Show Hide

Yeah I thought you meant he changed after she died! I'm with ya now