A suggestion

[PaulMacC]

I think it's a great guide and if you have nothing nice to say dont say it at all.

[O]

This will be usefull when i start to rate other peoples alts soon when i have the time thanks!

[Bibliophobia]

u did just waste ur time

but i understand

on hxf peeps giv like anythin 10/10

even hamheyelliot got like 2 10/10 i was like :S

Thanks for positive feedback, I know i wasted my time but i did it ages ago in the hols when I had Nothing to do lol

[-Eyeless-]

I think its really well thought out and Its a good Idea, I think some people on this forum just dont have a life and feel the need to spend all day posting Mean, Spitefull and over-opinionated views because they have nothing nice to say... :rolleyes:

[Hiro]

I wouldn't say that they saved as a JPEG being a fault.
I can post jpegs with the max quality, which is better than anything else.
It just depends what program people use to save.

If you said "saved in bad quality". Then I'd agree..


Also, I think more people should say what to improve if they think it's rubbish. Rather than just putting "2/10".
=/

[3.141]

I wouldn't say that they saved as a JPEG being a fault.
I can post jpegs with the max quality, which is better than anything else.
It just depends what program people use to save.

If you said "saved in bad quality". Then I'd agree..


Also, I think more people should say what to improve if they think it's rubbish. Rather than just putting "2/10".
=/

JPEG is generally the worst quality there is. It's fine sortof when you save images in JPEG on vista paint, but when veiwed on an XP device it looks terrible.

[Hiro]

Mhmm.
I guess.
usually works for me.

[Catzsy]

It is a good guide but everybody's standards are different. Good graphics artists would be more critical than me who just knows whether I like the concept or not. I would not like to be restrained in what marks I give.