Hosting Graphics - Please rate

[Cixso]

The entire star, it looks awful. Very warped star.

I'll reply in a second with new designs of the star.

Thanks to who has have replied with comments/feedback.

[Cixso]

EDIT:

I don't like any of the above 3 just to mention. But I created them anyway to see who may like them or not.

Sorry about the image 3 quality, the glow is way to thick I have realised.

[Excellent1]

EDIT:

I don't like any of the above 3 just to mention. But I created them anyway to see who may like them or not.

Sorry about the image 3 quality, the glow is way to thick I have realised.

I think it's the gradient I don't like, try doing a darker tone with some inner shadow

[Dentafrice]

The star looks too wide, which stretches it.

[Cixso]

They are nice.

Well done.

Thanks karl.

I think it's the gradient I don't like, try doing a darker tone with some inner shadow

Will do.

The star looks too wide, which stretches it.

Ok, I'll faff on with it.

[lAscend]

i like them all but the support icons are better

[Cixso]

i like them all but the support icons are better

Thank you.

I am editing the star still, I just can't get it right. If more people like the star on the first one than hate it I'll just stick with it.

You can't make something that everybody will like.

[Source]

Maybe I am missing something... but why get C & C on Icons if the person you have made them for already likes them... C & C on a logo is fine, but these are bog standard 2 minute buttons make this thread pointless imo.

I don't like them anyway, look cheap as the AA on the text as slightly dodgy :/

[Cixso]

Maybe I am missing something... but why get C & C on Icons if the person you have made them for already likes them... C & C on a logo is fine, but these are bog standard 2 minute buttons make this thread pointless imo.

Because how did I know they like them if I didn't create this thread?

I think your missing something obvious.

Don't post in something you find pointless then, otherwise your "pointless posting". You are still at it because of the TheUpload thread?

I don't like them anyway, look cheap as the AA on the text as slightly dodgy :/

The AA?

[Source]

Because how did I know they like them if I didn't create this thread?

Get opinions on msn. Not everything little thing in the world of graphics needs to have a new thread.

The AA?

Anti-Aliasing. You loose some definition like the joining bracket of the L

Font is boring aswel, go for something more modern.