Popstars - The Rivals

[Eamonn]

urgh i cant stand people who think girls aloud are better than the spice girls!

why not?

girls aloud are much more talented singers (nadine could easily outsing them all)
can dance just as well (cheryl could easily outdance them all)
hotter (sporty spice and a gold tooth ew. both have gingers, cancels out LOL.)

still spice girls are mint. they paved the way for girl groups, but if GA came out before spice girls, it could easily have been v. different.

[clueless]

because i dont believe girls aloud would have existed without spice girls!

[PaintYourTarget]

Long story short, I'd rather give Girls Aloud one.

[stickwitu]

why not?

girls aloud are much more talented singers (nadine could easily outsing them all)
can dance just as well (cheryl could easily outdance them all)
hotter (sporty spice and a gold tooth ew. both have gingers, cancels out LOL.)

still spice girls are mint. they paved the way for girl groups, but if GA came out before spice girls, it could easily have been v. different.

i don't believe that girls aloud are more talented.
i think both groups have their weak singers, nadine and mel c being the strongest from each - although nadine definitely isn't the best live (that's nicola and sarah exc. THAT performance on gmtv).

still, i prefer sugababes over both of those groups. they're a step ahead in live performances.

[Liz♥]

i don't believe that girls aloud are more talented.
i think both groups have their weak singers, nadine and mel c being the strongest from each - although nadine definitely isn't the best live (that's nicola and sarah exc. THAT performance on gmtv).

still, i prefer sugababes over both of those groups. they're a step ahead in live performances.

that's just one bad peformance. try the girls aloud party or how about you try watching them live. nerves of t.v shows such as x factor effect someones vocals and because of the fact they were made through a talent show emphasises on the fact they are talented. that's like saying leona lewis isn't talented then... they don't pick random girls, they were picked because of their talent

sugababes are so desperate they go to butlins and habbo whereas girls aloud can fill the o2 three times in a row and the sugababes can't fill it once and what's that got to tell you? a bigger fan base must mean people like them for a reason possibly................. sugababes are so desperate to keep alive, there's only 1 member remaining and one of them is in cbb

[Alkaz]

Im pretty sure girls aloud are popular world wide anyway, maybe not in america but in other big countries they are. I always seen them on utube in australia and other countries. And ye like liz said, they do anything they can for publicity. Also, the suga babes arent really the sugababes no more, two of the original three members left and 3 have been replaced snice then? Girls aloud are all still their.

[clueless]

you cant really base girls alouds talent on the fact that they won a talent competition because remember popstars was one of the first ones. if you listen to their auditions they really aren't that amazing. the standard has gone up so much and tons of people can sing just as well as they can.
i don't think they are talented, yeah they can dance and put on a show but singing wise they are pretty average.
not saying spice girls can sing but at least they have their originality to back them up.

[Virgin Mary]

If you're suddenly going to start comparing based on talent because it turns out Girls Aloud haven't sold the most records, then groups like Destiny's Child and Sugababes beat them. They lose out for not having a black in their group.

[stickwitu]

that's just one bad peformance. try the girls aloud party or how about you try watching them live. nerves of t.v shows such as x factor effect someones vocals and because of the fact they were made through a talent show emphasises on the fact they are talented. that's like saying leona lewis isn't talented then... they don't pick random girls, they were picked because of their talent

sugababes are so desperate they go to butlins and habbo whereas girls aloud can fill the o2 three times in a row and the sugababes can't fill it once and what's that got to tell you? a bigger fan base must mean people like them for a reason possibly................. sugababes are so desperate to keep alive, there's only 1 member remaining and one of them is in cbb

sorry but they're not that good, definitley not as good as you and their fanbase make out. they can sell out arenas but that doesn't neccesarily mean they're good - just more people like them because they're more typical cliche camp pop which is favoured more so in the UK. sounds like i hit an obvious nerve though with you attempting to **** off the babes.

and internationally, as far as talent goes Destiny's Child are the #1.

[dirrty]

destinys child best girl band everrrrrrrr