CC Threads

[Kardan]

Before the rule stated that 'don't just say it's bad, say something that could be improved' or something, but this was never followed and members just said things like 'that's rubbish' and never got warned. Apparently, it wasn't fair to warn those who were negative but not those who were positive regardless of it being written in the rule. The CC tags then came requiring CC whether it was good or bad, however, it looks like it's fell back into its old ways minorily too. A rewrite is definitely needed!

I agree Posts should have a discussion value, and not just a post for the sake of it, that's what spam is for

[Martin]

Okay, I have made a small update to the graphics forum rules, mainly the rule about CC, which is hopefully more clear now, and will prevent such posts as discussed in this thread being penalised for.

http://www.habboxforum.com/showthrea...94#post7340594


This should hopefully still elimiate short replies, but also ensure that people back up their reasons when making negative comments about peoples work, and offering improvements etc.

Does this look okay to everyone?

[Kardan]

Okay, I have made a small update to the graphics forum rules, mainly the rule about CC, which is hopefully more clear now, and will prevent such posts as discussed in this thread being penalised for.

http://www.habboxforum.com/showthrea...94#post7340594


This should hopefully still elimiate short replies, but also ensure that people back up their reasons when making negative comments about peoples work, and offering improvements etc.

Does this look okay to everyone?

Seems perfect to me

[Samantha]

Okay, I have made a small update to the graphics forum rules, mainly the rule about CC, which is hopefully more clear now, and will prevent such posts as discussed in this thread being penalised for.

http://www.habboxforum.com/showthrea...94#post7340594


This should hopefully still elimiate short replies, but also ensure that people back up their reasons when making negative comments about peoples work, and offering improvements etc.

Does this look okay to everyone?

So if they just say 'looks good' it's still an edit offence? So works for negative and positive?

[Jordan]

So if they just say 'looks good' it's still an edit offence? So works for negative and positive?

That always applied?

[Chris]

Looks fine now to me.

[Samantha]

That always applied?

No it hasn't

I got told it wasn't fair to warn people saying 'that's nice' and such unless they repeatedly did it?

[Kyle]

Okay, I have made a small update to the graphics forum rules, mainly the rule about CC, which is hopefully more clear now, and will prevent such posts as discussed in this thread being penalised for.

http://www.habboxforum.com/showthrea...94#post7340594


This should hopefully still elimiate short replies, but also ensure that people back up their reasons when making negative comments about peoples work, and offering improvements etc.

Does this look okay to everyone?

That's okay but still doesn't seem to leave any leeway for posts promoting discussion like the one asking what tutorial was used.

[Jordan]

No it hasn't

I got told it wasn't fair to warn people saying 'that's nice' and such unless they repeatedly did it?

I always thought the CC tags on a thread meant that any reply had to be constructive explaining what they did well and not just "love it" and what they did not so well and not just "don't like it sorry".

[Kyle]

No it hasn't

I got told it wasn't fair to warn people saying 'that's nice' and such unless they repeatedly did it?

I would say it is fair in non-CC threads unless it's obviously a post count boost attempt when they do a pigperson and go through every thread in the section, only read the first post and make a generic reply.