It was definetly rushed but Harry Potter films have always been. There's key parts in the book and I could only see one being used, and that was when Dumbledore says

It was definetly rushed but Harry Potter films have always been. There's key parts in the book and I could only see one being used, and that was when Dumbledore says"It was foolish of you to come here tonight Tom"
FORMERArticles Staff
News Reporter
'Council Ideas Monitor'
Forum Moderator
Help Desk Staff
Events Organiser
Competitions Staff (manager)
Joined Habbox full-time: 22-04-2005
Left Habbox full time: 20-08-2007
It was alright, sure, they cut out a lot but you gotta know they can't put EVERYTHING in it, else it'd be too long.
I was a little disappointed, especially with the flashback with the marauders and young!snape being cut so short, cause that was one of my favorite parts in the book. In my opinion, the fourth movie was the worst and the third movie was the best. Still, the fifth wasn't too bad. I actually enjoyed it for the most part.. but I'm going to stick to the books, tbh.
Seriously, you lot are saying you can't put EVERTHING in ''/
Yes I know that, I am not completely ignorant to the fact you can't
But they cut out the most important pars of the 5th book, when Dumbledore tells Harry about the prophecy personally in full detail and explains its significance.
Edited by Garion (Forum Super Moderator): Please do not have images in your signature that exceed the 150 Pixel height limit for your usergroup.
i thought it was great! i had very low expectations but it was very well done.
It was a brilliant film, enough said.
Are you saying the film was rubbish as a stand-alone film, or compared to the other films, or compared to the book?
It's kind of official that Order of the Phoenix was the worst book out of them all.
I didn't pick up a lot from the book though as when I was reading it, I was "racing" a girl in my class to see who could finish it first, which I regret, cos I'm never gonna read it properly. Wouldn't be any point reading it now cos I know the ending
The film was good but it just lacked something. Dunno what. All films have been like that recently, Order of the Phoenix, Shrek III. I'm hoping that the Simpsons Movie won't be the same.
I loved ootp my favirote HP film yet. I really disliked the book it was slow to start and really boring.
The simpsons movie i think will be terrible. it isn't the original writers. the show has gone down hill the past few years, ive stopped watching it completely. i'll see the movie, but im not getting my hopes up.
It was okay, considering I never actually read the book for this one because the first few chapters were utter crap.
I would have liked it more of the Order of the Phoenix and the Death Eaters had longer fight scenes :rolleyes:
Want to hide these adverts? Register an account for free!