Room Separator - Take 2

[Nielez]

Its probably for the idea he made, and it IS pretty good, the whole alt is quite simple so:

alt: 5/10 (too simple)
idea 9/10 (pretty good)
overall: 7/10

[:kader]

3/10, simple opacity changing, no way elite, sorry.

[wootzy]

Its probably for the idea he made,

its not about the idea its about the quality

[P@ND@]

its not about the idea its about the quality

And if it was for the idea it wouldn't be original.
Have been done several times.

[Xero]

Why's this in elite? Its simple, and as P@ND@ said, its been done before. He even made errors when doing the green drawing of it on the room layout selection

[Kyle441]

Okay its great, i was gonna say it wasn't a good idea because the wall was blocking your view, but then you did the see-through wall so that was good. 10/10

[A4AOwen]

Wow! Thats great! 9/10.

[Pawf]

He even made errors when doing the green drawing of it on the room layout selection

Please show me where.

Also I think it's established this doesn't deserve to be in the elites. How about helping me mke it better? Or is that beyond you?

[Paul]

He even made errors when doing the green drawing of it on the room layout selection

One of the four errors I noticed.
The errors which I noticed are;

1. The center wall in the green thumb should be more to the right.
2. An un-needed wall line at the top and wrong shading.
3. A missing isometric line in the opacity-altered version.
4. This being in the Elite section.

[Pawf]

OMG! WILL YOU GIVE IT A REST WITH THE "THIS SHOULDN'T BE IN THE ELITE SECTION" ?! I'VE HAD LOADS OF NEGATIVE REP ABOUT IT AND I DIDN'T EVEN ASK FOR IT TO BE PUT IN! I DIDN'T EVEN THINK IT WOULD GO IN! READ THE 3RD FREAKING POST!!!!!!