Should X Factor reject Gamu Nhengu be deported from the UK?

[Bun]

mugabe gonna get ya

Edited by HotelUser (Forum Moderator): Please don't post pointlessly, thanks.

[Samantha]

I feel that she shouldn't be treat differently but some illegal immigrants who are definitely in danger of being abused/killed etc then maybe they should be allowed to stay. Under the condition that, they have one of the worst properties, because frankly I live in a rubbish house and my family is in dire need of a bungalow but the council will not help. So the government shouldn't for Gamu and her family in that respect.

Confused myself a little.

Basically, Gamu should be deported along with her family.
Immigrants should be considered to stay if they get a valid visa.
They shouldn't be recommended for benefits or anything.
They should get worse thought of than the countires 'proper' residents, well not necassarily 'worse thought of' just have worse amenities.

[mr.iain]

yes. she should be. period

[Accipiter]

Think you've overlooked some major things, what extent would you go to, to stop your family returning to a place of hell.

[Apple]

Think you've overlooked some major things, what extent would you go to, to stop your family returning to a place of hell.

I agree with you, this is what I said earlier on in the debate:

I don't blame her for not wanting to go back so good luck to her. Back home she will probably have to walk like 5 miles for a dirty bucket of water that's contaminated with aids.

[Samantha]

Well of course everyone's different! If it was your family yes you would try your hardest to protect them, in which Gamu did, the first time on the x factor she said she was doing it for her mum, to give everything back to her what she has done for her and her siblings.
But she didn't get far enough in the competition, it's no one's fault really, people blamed Cheryl but she was just doing what's right, at the end of the day, anyone should stick by their family. I know not all of them do but Gamu is trying to fight for something, that will help her life, instead of going back to Zimbabwe, which may put her at risk. But if this happens, at least she should be proud, that she tried to fight something. Even if it's a lose-lose battle.

[Oleh]

I agree with you, this is what I said earlier on in the debate:

Maybe she could import a few million bottles of spring water from all the benefits she earned

[Accipiter]

Maybe she could import a few million bottles of spring water from all the benefits she earned

Wow, just, wow.

Ignorance is bliss, she didn't earn that, her mother got it (anyone care to tell me how she "stole") cause i hope its not just "stealing off our taxes" when theres probably a hand full of peoples parents who are living on the dole but got somewhere on that show.

If she stole some other way then as said care to explain

[Oleh]

Well she's obviously benefiting from the publicity which is paying her.

[Accipiter]

Doesn't matter if the publicity does pay her (which i highly doubt it will be) she'd much rather be a hard working citizen by the looks of it.