Anne Frank Might Be Alive

[MightyMagician]

Why do you think she needs to hide from the public? There are other Jewish survivors who came into the public eye and educate about the holocaust and share their experiences? If this risk you are imagining was there then the others would have gone into hiding too.

Already addressed above.

[Red]

How?! Many lived through transfer to diff camps and lived to testify to the gas chambers existence.

[MightyMagician]

The difference is that she already knew about the gas chambers beforehand, and it was written in the diary.

[FlyingJesus]

You can still kill people while on the run. Nice try.

Good luck sneaking into post-war Germany from South America when you're the world's most wanted criminal, and then managing to somehow get close enough to a celebrity survivor of the camps to off them. There's also no motive since there was no Nazi government to protect any more, and with no means or motive there is no threat. You're just making things up and choosing to believe the most outrageous things for a theory that changes literally nothing in all of history anyway

The difference is that she already knew about the gas chambers beforehand, and it was written in the diary.

And you're assuming that a little girl locked away in hiding would be the only person who knew about them? And she alone would be at risk as opposed to those around her for what reason? Nothing that you're claiming makes any sense

[MightyMagician]

Slowly picks part post.

Good luck sneaking into post-war Germany from South America when you're the world's most wanted criminal, and then managing to somehow get close enough to a celebrity survivor of the camps to off them. There's also no motive since there was no Nazi government to protect any more, and with no means or motive there is no threat. You're just making things up and choosing to believe the most outrageous things for a theory that changes literally nothing in all of history anyway



And you're assuming that a little girl locked away in hiding would be the only person who knew about them? And she alone would be at risk as opposed to those around her for what reason? Nothing that you're claiming makes any sense

Her diary sold hundreds of millions of copies and still is, and she was a gas chamber witness, which she wrote about said gas chambers in the diary. I never said she was the only witness. I said Mengele was an example, he wasn't the only one. Killing someone to protect your own ass is motive, assuming Anne went public. That's a threat.

[FlyingJesus]

The Nuremberg Trials ended on 1st October 1946, the diaries weren't published until 1947 so she was no "celebrity" until long after her death and the end of the trials, and considering Anne died before the war was even over there would not only be no point in faking her death but also no way of doing it. You really are stretching as far as you can trying to grab on to a theory that simply doesn't hold any water.

No reason to do it in the first place, no reason to keep up the charade all her life, no reason to ever believe that she didn't die a horrific death other than a bad photo that doesn't even look like her and the writings of a fact-blind Holocaust denier

[GommeInc]

You clearly don't know what punishing somebody is, and it's laughable that you consider moving a thread to a different section as some form of punishment. Giving the user a warning is a punishment, moving a thread to a more suiting section is not punishing somebody.

Warning someone is not a punishment. Are you of earth? The Spam forum is not a more suited forum - only you think so. Everyone else is of the opinion it is more suited here. Before your useless comment it was a decent thread, then you spoiled it.

This is such a stupid and illogical comment. Genuinely expected better from you.

It's not a comment. It's a fact. Only you wanted it moved to Spam. It was reverted because no one else thought it was a good idea.

I don't think it belongs in spam because I disagree with it, I think it belongs in spam because it's the same fringe theory rubbish that Dragga posted, which was also moved to spam. In fact, some of Dragga's threads which were moved actually had more potential for discussion (such as this one) than this thread.

Doesn't mean I agree with that decision. I've said for years that the Spam forum is misused. You clearly disagree with the Dragga threads being moved there so I'm not sure what you're point is. You want a thread moved to Spam because... you want another daft decision made? Hardly betters the forum.

It's funny that you simply dismiss him as deranged (jumping on the bandwagon and back to your mob rules attitude) and use that as grounds to suggest that all his threads belonged in spam, rather than judging them independently rather than by who made it.

The last thread I ever saw of his was so messed up I go by that. Didn't say they all were, but from that last thread I saw of his he came off as a bit paranoid.

What decent sources have been provided in this thread? Other than a badly made youtube video I can't think of anything else.

Tallcoolguy700 gave names of people who have always given contradicting information which have never made sense. Even if you disagree with the idea she's still alive, there is a lot of scope for discussion about why the information contradicts and why there is no cement information on her time of death. Chucking it in Spam when it is not "pointless" seems counter-productive. Your only contribution to this thread is saying "this is a stupid thread" without actually giving a reason why. Before that, a good discussion was going on that was sullied by some unwanted pedanticism based on some daft reasoning:

Other threads were moved to Spam,
You disagreed with their removal
BUT, you think this should be removed for continuity because it is similar to those threads.

It's like you purposely want to cut off your nose to spite your face :/

EDIT:

This seems a bit like a pointless discussion seeing as there is a real discussion going on proving this thread isn't pointless. It's actually quite interesting. Possibly one of the few interesting threads this forum has seen for a while.

[The Don]

Warning someone is not a punishment. Are you of earth? The Spam forum is not a more suited forum - only you think so. Everyone else is of the opinion it is more suited here. Before your useless comment it was a decent thread, then you spoiled it.

Issuing a warning is not a punishment but relocating a thread is?

It's not a comment. It's a fact. Only you wanted it moved to Spam. It was reverted because no one else thought it was a good idea.

It's a fact that what's most popular is always the rule? So absurd.

Doesn't mean I agree with that decision. I've said for years that the Spam forum is misused. You clearly disagree with the Dragga threads being moved there so I'm not sure what you're point is. You want a thread moved to Spam because... you want another daft decision made? Hardly betters the forum.

Learn to read posts properly, I never said that I disagreed with Dragga's threads being moved, in fact that point is one of my main reasons for suggesting this thread be moved.

The last thread I ever saw of his was so messed up I go by that. Didn't say they all were, but from that last thread I saw of his he came off as a bit paranoid.

He made loads of threads, and you're judging them all based on one particular one?

Tallcoolguy700 gave names of people who have always given contradicting information which have never made sense. Even if you disagree with the idea she's still alive, there is a lot of scope for discussion about why the information contradicts and why there is no cement information on her time of death. Chucking it in Spam when it is not "pointless" seems counter-productive.

Giving names is now considered decent sources? Lmao alrighty then. Look at the rest of the comments in this thread, even when presented with solid points he simply creates some ridiculous excuse to counter them.

Your only contribution to this thread is saying "this is a stupid thread" without actually giving a reason why. Before that, a good discussion was going on that was sullied by some unwanted pedanticism based on some daft reasoning:

That's virtually all you've contributed to this thread, if you care to look I've actually been replying on topic for the past few pages...

Other threads were moved to Spam,
You disagreed with their removal
BUT, you think this should be removed for continuity because it is similar to those threads.

It's like you purposely want to cut off your nose to spite your face :/

Nope, not at all. Learn to read posts properly and then come back to me, where did I say I disagreed with them being moved to spam?

This seems a bit like a pointless discussion seeing as there is a real discussion going on proving this thread isn't pointless. It's actually quite interesting. Possibly one of the few interesting threads this forum has seen for a while.

If you consider this tiring argument (not mine and yours, but Tallcoolguys vs everyone else) real discussion and one of the better threads on the forum then you really are a wet blanket. Nothing he's saying makes any sense, and his entire argument is built upon one picture of a girl that kinda-sort of-doesn't look like Anne Frank.

[MightyMagician]

*REMOVED*

Edited by Nick (Assistant Forum Manager): Please don't be rude towards others.

[The Don]

*REMOVED*

Calm down bobby! Believing there's no conspiracy surrounding the death of Anne Frank doesn't make me simple minded.