favourite lord of the rings film and why

[Kirk]

I liked the 3rd one best, though it didn't have as much battle scenes in it as the second one, it was more powerful than the second one, and thats what made it more enjoyable for me. Though all three movies were great, I went to one of the places where some of it was shot, you can't tell a movie was made there.

[Gamaya]

sam to frodo: "I took the Ring when you were paralysed by that spider"

frodo to sam: "Oh, so anyone can carry it, then?"

*sam looks at Peter Jackson*

Peter Jackson: *shrugs*


that was also left out...

anyway, enough for ripping movies to shreds.. number 2 for me was definitely the most enjoyable, even though some may argue that 3 was the best. number 1 definitely isn't the best, though (that makes it the worst..)

[Simonac55]

Well my favorite one is the 3rd because the ending is always my favorite part. I liked the part when Frodo was fighting the spider and when he tries to throw the ring in the fire