Lady Gaga or Madonna?

They're both legendary pop icons but if you had to choose, honestly who would you pick? They are both top pop queens in different generations but who do you reckon is the best?

I have to go for Lady Gaga. Her piano/keyboard skills mixed in with her singing is just brilliant. I've never seen Madonna do anything like that. Gaga's live performances are always amazing and unique, but in terms of being unique, so is madonna.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8Er2esw0YI

Her skills are just amazing and I don't think Madonna has ever done anything like that.

So, Madonna or Lady Gaga?

both. why is it that the media (and then everyone else) must pit the female artists against each other and argue that you can't like more than one, but we never see this with male artists? like srsly, it's ridiculous.

Yeah I admit the media do go over the top but I am just simply asking for an opinion which you have given, both.

I do like some Madonna songs, but I prefer Lady Gaga. Much more unique in my opinion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dirrty

both. why is it that the media (and then everyone else) must pit the female artists against each other and argue that you can't like more than one, but we never see this with male artists? like srsly, it's ridiculous.

---

This literally sums up everything I was going to say^.

I see no point in fighting over artists, sometimes they release good songs, sometimes bad :S - Madonna and Lady GaGa are equally good in my eyes...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dirrty

both. why is it that the media (and then everyone else) must pit the female artists against each other and argue that you can't like more than one, but we never see this with male artists? like srsly, it's ridiculous.

---

yeah exactly

I like both but obviously I prefer Gaga for several reasons

I don't really like Madonna, I prefer Lady Gaga although she's a bit crazy..but I think that's what I love about her tbh :P

Hmm not sure really. I like them both, but lady gaga is a bit more unique.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jordan

I do like some Madonna songs, but I prefer Lady Gaga. Much more unique in my opinion.

---

Gaga, even said in an interview once that she's going to be the new Madonna with extras.
So in a way she has kind of adapted Madonnas style

I personally like them both, Gaga gets on my nerves sometimes, and I don't get why she dresses so weird.. Some say it's individuality but I say she looks stupid in some of the stuff she wears, Lately she's calmed down which is nice to see!
However I like Lady gaga's latest album - The way it sounds more 80's than anything else, is brilliant. I love her Music style right now.

I have no conclusion to this message.

gaga for the voice and songs, madonna for the looks altho she's 53

i like lady gaga's songs more, infact i don't like any of madonna's but i still don't like either of them as a person :S at least lady gaga isn't a bitter old ***** tho

GaGa, I do like Madonna I just prefer GaGa aha. :P

Definitely Lady Gaga, Madonna sounds awful imo.

I like both of them but I listen to lady gag more than I listen to madonna :P

Lady Gaga just because I really like most of her song and I don't really like many of Madonna's :p

Madonna, by miles... the majority is going to be GaGa though as Madonna is pretty old school.

Madonna by far!

madonna....

I'd say Lady Gaga. Madonna is ugly weird, just saying.

I like both in moderation but in terms of who's the more iconic it has to be Madonna surely. Also I'm getting kinda disillusioned with Gaga as she seems to care more about making messages than making good music - let's face it, she's at her best when she just makes simple dance tracks like the majority of her first album

Lady Gaga legendary? Yeah, okay. Maybe one day.

I doubt Gaga will still be doing her thing at 53. I'm betting Madonna will leave much more of an impression than she ever will. And let's face it, Lady Gaga is an early Madonna rip-off.

I'm not a fan of any of the artists to be honest with you. If I was to choose it would have to be Lady Gaga though, she's got a great voice and some pretty good songs.

personally pick gaga, but I'm far more familiar with her stuff, however madonnas american life album is really great!

im fed up of gaga's mother monster and put your paws up crap. Wish she would make more songs like Eh Eh, Summerboy andPaparazzi

I like both, but I'd say I prefer Lady Gaga's songs.

madonna like 96-2007 really enjoyed the majority of her singles. gaga i liked originally but now feels like she only does things to make a scene, which is boring.