Rihanna pulls out of X Factor

[dirrty]

this thread aint about beyonce copying whoever, so who gives a flying ****.

i just hope beyonce don't try to outshine anyone lol

[TopManTim]

It's called having a stylist so don't get up on Beyonce's back when she's a much more talented artist than Rihanna ever will be. If I Were A Boy was written by BC Jean and produced by Tony Gad on the basis that it would go towards B's new album. It's not an uncommon process at all, Rihanna doesn't have a single writing credit on GGGB so don't try pulling that card.



You can make up for lack of vocal talent by performing well (eg. Britney, Janet) - she doesn't dance, and she lacks charisma. I haven't seen a single performance by her which makes me go "wow, she really is talented" when there are a lot better artists who get ignored for her.

-Beyonce also doesn't have a single writing credit on her album
-Your digging Rihannas performances even though Beyonce has been doing the same tired routine for single ladies everywhere, none of them are any different, all just the same moves.

Edit: Yeah this has gone a bit off-topic. I also hope that Beyonce doesn't take the focus off Alex but I think it will happen.

[Captain]

Rihanna is way more successful than Beyonce :/ Who's had more hits as a solo artist? Rihanna.

[FlyingJesus]

Rihanna is way more successful than Beyonce :/ Who's had more hits as a solo artist? Rihanna.

Who's married to the richest man in hip hop?
Who's more respected as an artist and a market enterprise?
Who has more money?
Who is more of a household name?

Then tell me which is more successful lol.

[Captain]

Who's married to the richest man in hip hop?
Who's more respected as an artist and a market enterprise?
Who has more money?
Who is more of a household name?

Then tell me which is more successful lol.

Being married to the richest person in hip hop doesn't make you successful. Thats like calling Danielle Lloyd a success because she's dating a rich footballer.

Id say Rihanna is more respected as an artist and is more marketable.

Of course Beyonce has more money, she's been around alot longer than Rihanna. Amy Winehouse has alot of money (£20M+) that doesn't mean shes a success?

Rihanna is more popular than Beyonce.

[dirrty]

Rihanna is way more successful than Beyonce :/ Who's had more hits as a solo artist? Rihanna.

omg LOL u cant b serious
beyonce has sold more than rihanna (and with destinys childs sales, beyonce will always outsell rihanna). even though its not all about sales, beyonce has marketed herself much better than rihanna and has a better voice than her, which is extremly obvious.

soz yh, but beyonce is out of rihannas big foreheaded league.

beyonce is more respected as an artist as she actually writes a decent amount of her songs, unlike rihanna.

edit; beyonce was the second highest paid musician between June 2007 and June 2008, with earnings of $80 million (£53 million). rihanna deffo wouldn't earn that much.

[FlyingJesus]

Being married to the richest person in hip hop doesn't make you successful. Thats like calling Danielle Lloyd a success because she's dating a rich footballer.

Being able to get whatever you want isn't being successful?

Id say Rihanna is more respected as an artist and is more marketable.

Your opinion may be that you prefer Rihanna's music over Beyonce but you cannot seriously say that she is more respected or marketable than a superdiva lol

Rihanna is more popular than Beyonce.

No she's just done more recently

[Captain]

omg LOL u cant b serious
beyonce has sold more than rihanna (and with destinys childs sales, beyonce will always outsell rihanna).

Thats why I said, as a solo artist.

[dirrty]

Thats why I said, as a solo artist.

nevertheless, beyonce is still and will always be more successful than rihanna. beyonce can be more versatile with her voice and overall appearance, whereas rihanna has to stick to a certain look and cant do much else than she already is doing currently.

overall, beyonce has branched herself in all areas (clothing, acting, singing etc.) and in all of those areas, have been successful. rihanna wouldnt be able to do that imo, and if she did, not as good as beyonce.

[Captain]

Rihanna has so many different looks its ridiculous. How can you possibly say she had to stick to one look?

Beyonces career is maybe triple the length of Rihannas therefore she is obviously going to venture other different markets such as clothing and acting. Oh and incase you didn't know, Rihanna has her own range of umbrellas,handbags and is the face of some perfume.