The official X Factor Thread

[CJW93]

Alot of bands have a lead singer and Jls are great

[Geraint]

pukes on JLS and having only one singer. When the chorus kicks in and they all sing like some cheesy boy band from the 80's. I mean when they sang that Westlife song, it gave them the chance to have a few lines to themselves but noo it's just that one guy, if they win. ewwwwww it's like the male version of pcd but gone bad

you've claimed they are bad, then compared them to PCD. great one.

[Liz♥]

you've claimed they are bad, then compared them to PCD. great one.

"pcd gone bad"

[Captain]

the english are the only country not to. haha.

thats because england have grasped the meaning of talent. We dont vote just because they're from our country we vote for them because of their talent.

[CJW93]

Thats why Ruth got as far as she did

[Geraint]

"pcd gone bad"

I know you said that but the first bit you suggest that "one singer groups" don't work then said that PCD do.

thats because england have grasped the meaning of talent. We dont vote just because they're from our country we vote for them because of their talent.

no, it's more to do with the counties of england vote for each rather than the country as a whole.

[Urnuph]

alexandra burke to win.
1. best singer/voice on there
2. deserves it the most
3. she is beautiful

[Captain]

Compare the quantity of people from counties and countries.

[Geraint]

Compare the quantity of people from counties and countries.

wales - 3 million
n. ireland - 2 million
scotland - 5 million


aint too bad really.

[Liz♥]

I know you said that but the first bit you suggest that "one singer groups" don't work then said that PCD do.



no, it's more to do with the counties of england vote for each rather than the country as a whole.

this is about singing and i'm going to judge it on that, PCD didn't form through a singing competiton and the only reason they're big is because of the catchy songs that are produced for them. They've been critisized hundreds of times about the fact that Nicole is the only one singing and the 'lead' in JLS is even that good to lead the whole group I don't think. Alex puts emotion & passion into her songs, that's why she nearly broke down in tears in the Beyonce duet and don't say she was doing it for Sympathy because when Beyonce sang at the EMA's this year, after the performance she broke down into tears as she was so emotional from the song. Alex deserves this, she's a world class star, she's like Leona Lewis (wow she can sing as good as her...?) and the passion & emotion she puts in her music then she'll get far.